Abigail's Baby Registry
Abigail & Caleb Kartner
Madison, WI
April 12, 2026
We are expecting! Please join us in welcoming the newest little Kartner. As first time parents, we are immensely grateful for any and all help. That being said, we’d love to keep all items for a long long time! Colors should be automatically selected in each listing, but if not, we ask that you select some sort of neutral color (black, grey, white, and some red or navy blue will match the nursery!).
Most wanted
Most wantedDr. Brown's Fold & Freeze Bottle Tote, Travel Baby Bottle Insulated Cooler Bag, Store Up to 6 Baby Bottles, Black, BPA Free
$17.99
Most wantedPortable Bottle Warmer for Travel, 2-Min Fast Heating Baby Bottle Warmer,12.8oz Formula Container to Go for Breastmilk, Formula Dispenser with Long-Lasting Keep Warm Function
$48.44
Most wantedMomcozy S9 Pro Upgraded Wearable Breast Pump, Hands-Free Design with Extended Battery Life & LED Display, Double Electric Portable Pump with 2 Modes & 9 Levels, 24mm, 2-Pack, Gray
$101.99
Most wantedBottle Warmer, GROWNSY 8-in-1 Fast Baby Milk Warmer with Timer for Breastmilk or Formula, Accurate Temperature Control, with Defrost, Sterili-zing, Keep, Heat Baby Food Jars Function
$39.99
Most wantedGROWNSY All-in-One Bottle Washer and Sterilizer and Dryer
Still needs $318.99
Most wantedPortable Baby Highchair for Months Infants and Toddlers with 5 Point Harness Convertible Comfortable Seat for Cozy Eating Table Sit Up High Chair and Seats for Sitting Up Back Booster Feeding Chairs
$49.99
Most wantedJoymor Modern Mini Crib - Space-Saving Compact Crib with Wheels
joymor Icon
$109.99
Most wantedOwlet Dream Sock Smart Baby Monitor - Mint
Still needs $328.90
Most wantedPortable Diaper Changing Pad with Shoulder Strap, Detachable Travel Changing Pad with Baby Wipes Pocket, Gifts for Baby Shower, Newborn Girls and Boys (Black)
$24.99
Most wantedBlissful Diary Vegan Leather Baby Changing Pad with Waterproof & Wipe-Clean PU Cover, Standard Size Cozy Diaper Changing Pad for Dresser and Table, Light Gray
$39.99
Most wantedDiaper Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail | Easiest to Use | Just Step – Drop – Done | Doesn’t Absorb Odors | Most Economical Refill System | 70% Recycled Materials | EKO White
$39.99
Most wantedEveryday Diaper Bag Backpack: The Ultimate Diaper Bag Backpack by TBG – Tactical Baby Gear
tacticalbabygear Icon
$200.00
Note from Abigail and Caleb:
Most wantedCloud Carry-on
baggu Icon
$78.00
Note from Abigail and Caleb:
Wants: 2
Most wantedKeaBabies Baby Wrap Carrier - All in 1 Original Baby Carrier Newborn to Toddler Sling, Easy to Wear, Hands Free Bonding, Lightweight, Breathable Infant Wraps (Classic Gray)
$29.96
Note from Abigail and Caleb:
Most wantedS-1™ Stroller by Tactical Baby Gear
tacticalbabygear Icon
$500.00
Most wantedTactical Baby Gear S-1™ Bassinet by TBG
tacticalbabygear Icon
$180.00
Most wantedErgonomic Lumbar Support Baby Carrier for Infants to Toddlers (8-33 lbs), Cozy and Lightweight Military Baby Carrier for Big and Tall Parents-Jungle Green
$119.99
Note from Abigail and Caleb:
Most wantedGraco Pack 'n Play Close2Baby Playard - Derby
Still needs $219.99
Most wantedIngenuity Keep Cozy 3-in-1 Grow with Me Vibrating Baby Bouncer Seat & Infant to Toddler Rocker, Vibrations & Toy Bar, 0-30 Months Up to 40 lbs (Linden)
$59.99
Feeding
Wants: 2
32-Pack Leakproof 4oz Glass Baby Food Jars With Lids - BPA Free, Freezer & Microwave Safe
$28.99
Ganiza Smoothie Blender, 900W Blenders for Shakes and Smoothies, 15-Piece Personal Blender and Grinder Combo for Kitchen, Smoothies Maker with 4 BPA-Free Portable Cup, Nutritious Recipe
$48.99
PandaEar Silicone Baby Feeding Set| 2 Pack Silicone Divided Suction Plate and 2 Pack Tiny Cup with 2 Spoons 2 Forks| Baby Led Weaning Supplies Self Feeding Eating Utensils (Light Tan/Walnut)
$13.95
2 Pack Nursing Pillow Cover Grey and Navy for Infant, Snug Fits Boppy Nursing Pillows, Breastfeeding Nursing Pillow Slipcovers Super Soft, for Breastfeeding Moms, Navy & Gray Star
$12.98
Nursing Cover for Breastfeeding, 360°Full Coverage Nursing Poncho, Rayon Soft & Breathable Breastfeeding Cover up (Smooth Rayon, Knit Grey)
$11.99
Wants: 2
Muslin Burp Cloths for Baby 100% Cotton Burping Cloths for Unisex, Boy, Girl - Large 20'' by 10'' Newborn Essentials Ultra Soft Absorbent Milk Spit Up Rags - 12 Pack - White+Deep Bean Paste Series
$21.99
Lansinoh Breast Therapy Packs, Hot and Cold Breast-Pads with 2 Soft Covers, Postpartum Essentials for Nipple Pain Relief, Mastitis, Engorgement, Support for Breastfeeding and Pump Aid, 2 Pack
$11.97 Was $14.99
lansinoh Icon
from $8.65
Boppy New Bare Naked Nursing Pillow - Bare Naked
$39.99
Silverette Silver Nursing Cups - Regular
$61.90
silveretteusa Icon
from $59.90
Wants: 2
Lansinoh Lanolin Nipple Cream
$8.97 Was $10.99
Lansinoh Washable Nursing Pads (10 Count)
$14.99
lansinoh Icon
from $13.64
Babylist Sippy Cup Box
$25.99 Was $32.46
Lansinoh Milk Storage Bags - 200
$25.99 Was $29.99
lansinoh Icon
from $23.78
Wants: 3
Dr. Brown's Anti-colic Options+ Narrow Baby Bottle Starter Gift Set - Clear/Blue
$29.99
Wants: 2
AEIOU Bib (2 Pack) - Sage/Oat Milk
$19.00
Boon Lawn Countertop Drying Rack - Green
$19.99
booninc Icon
from $19.99
Most wantedDr. Brown's Fold & Freeze Bottle Tote, Travel Baby Bottle Insulated Cooler Bag, Store Up to 6 Baby Bottles, Black, BPA Free
$17.99
Most wantedPortable Bottle Warmer for Travel, 2-Min Fast Heating Baby Bottle Warmer,12.8oz Formula Container to Go for Breastmilk, Formula Dispenser with Long-Lasting Keep Warm Function
$48.44
Most wantedMomcozy S9 Pro Upgraded Wearable Breast Pump, Hands-Free Design with Extended Battery Life & LED Display, Double Electric Portable Pump with 2 Modes & 9 Levels, 24mm, 2-Pack, Gray
$101.99
Most wantedBottle Warmer, GROWNSY 8-in-1 Fast Baby Milk Warmer with Timer for Breastmilk or Formula, Accurate Temperature Control, with Defrost, Sterili-zing, Keep, Heat Baby Food Jars Function
$39.99
Most wantedGROWNSY All-in-One Bottle Washer and Sterilizer and Dryer
Still needs $318.99
Most wantedPortable Baby Highchair for Months Infants and Toddlers with 5 Point Harness Convertible Comfortable Seat for Cozy Eating Table Sit Up High Chair and Seats for Sitting Up Back Booster Feeding Chairs
$49.99
Sleeping
Wants: 2
Crib Sheets for Boys or Girls 2 Pack, Fitted Crib Sheet for Standard Size Crib and Toddler Mattresses, Soft and Breathable Material, Grey & Navy
$11.99
Aden + Anais Essentials Cotton Wrap Swaddles (3 Pack) - Twinkle, 0-3 Months, 3
$44.99
KeaBabies Lumi Muslin Swaddle Blankets - Corals
$19.96
Most wantedJoymor Modern Mini Crib - Space-Saving Compact Crib with Wheels
joymor Icon
$109.99
Bed Sheet Straps, Sopito Adjustable Elastic Fitted Sheet Corner Holders Straps to Stay in Place, Non-Slip Fasteners Clips Compatible for Crib to King Size Bed, White 4Pcs
$6.99
Most wantedOwlet Dream Sock Smart Baby Monitor - Mint
Still needs $328.90
Diapering
Wants: 3
Aquaphor Baby Healing Ointment Advanced Therapy Skin Protectant, Dry Skin and Diaper Rash Ointment, 7 Oz Tube
$12.58
Wants: Unlimited
The Honest Company Baby Wipes - Pattern Play, 720 Count
$44.99
Wants: Unlimited
Pampers Pampers Swaddlers - 3 (168 Count)
$55.94
Wants: Unlimited
Pampers Pampers Swaddlers - 2 (84 Count)
$28.22
Wants: Unlimited
Pampers Pampers Swaddlers - 1 (164 Count)
$44.94
Wants: Unlimited
Pampers Pampers Swaddlers - Newborn (140 Count)
$44.94
Most wantedPortable Diaper Changing Pad with Shoulder Strap, Detachable Travel Changing Pad with Baby Wipes Pocket, Gifts for Baby Shower, Newborn Girls and Boys (Black)
$24.99
Most wantedBlissful Diary Vegan Leather Baby Changing Pad with Waterproof & Wipe-Clean PU Cover, Standard Size Cozy Diaper Changing Pad for Dresser and Table, Light Gray
$39.99
Wants: Unlimited
Diaper Dekor Classic Diaper Pail Refills | 2 Count Unscented | Exclusive End-of-Liner Marking | Quick & Easy to Replace | Most Economical Refill System | for Original and Eko Style Pails
$12.99
Most wantedDiaper Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail | Easiest to Use | Just Step – Drop – Done | Doesn’t Absorb Odors | Most Economical Refill System | 70% Recycled Materials | EKO White
$39.99
Baby Gear
Most wantedEveryday Diaper Bag Backpack: The Ultimate Diaper Bag Backpack by TBG – Tactical Baby Gear
tacticalbabygear Icon
$200.00
Go Pouch Set
baggu Icon
$40.00
Packing Cube Set
baggu Icon
$36.00
Most wantedCloud Carry-on
baggu Icon
$78.00
Wants: 3
NUK 100% Silicone Comfy Orthodontic Pacifiers, 0-6 Months, Neutral Fashion, Timeless Collection, 5 Count
$9.49
Wants: 2
Skip Hop Baby Silicone Pacifier Holder Case with Easy-Access Opening and Strap, Fits 2 Pacifiers, Oat
$9.99
Aden + Anais Snuggle Knit Multi-Use Cover - Heather Grey
$34.99
Baby Carrier Pro, MOMTORY Safety-Certified 6-in-1 Ultra Storage Baby Carrier Newborn to Toddler, Detachable Baby Holder Carrier with Hip Seat, Ergonomic Cozy Baby Body Carrier for 7-50lbs, Khaki
$42.59
Wants: 2
Most wantedKeaBabies Baby Wrap Carrier - All in 1 Original Baby Carrier Newborn to Toddler Sling, Easy to Wear, Hands Free Bonding, Lightweight, Breathable Infant Wraps (Classic Gray)
$29.96
Most wantedS-1™ Stroller by Tactical Baby Gear
tacticalbabygear Icon
$500.00
Most wantedTactical Baby Gear S-1™ Bassinet by TBG
tacticalbabygear Icon
$180.00
7 Pcs Braided Pacifier Clip, Pacifier Clips for Boys & Baby Girls, Pacifier Holder Clip Binky Clips
$7.52
Most wantedErgonomic Lumbar Support Baby Carrier for Infants to Toddlers (8-33 lbs), Cozy and Lightweight Military Baby Carrier for Big and Tall Parents-Jungle Green
$119.99
JL Childress Backseat Butler Car Organizer - Black
$44.99
Dreambaby Adjusta-Car Shade Stretch-It, Shape-It, Fit-It (2 Pack)
$24.99
Out of stock
Sprucely Back Seat Mirror - Black
$18.99
Graco Turn2Me 3-in-1 Car Seat - Cambridge
Still needs $439.99
Health & Safety
Frida Baby Not-Too-Cold-To-Hold Teether
$9.96 Was $9.99
Frida Baby Baby Basics Kit
$39.97 Was $39.99
Frida Baby 3-in-1 True Temp Thermometer
$19.99
Bathing
ezpz Baby-Led Toothbrush - Pewter
$8.99
Sprucely Brush & Comb Set - Cantaloupe
$12.99
The Honest Company Wash and Lotion Bundle - Calm (Lavender)
$19.49
Lambs & Ivy Snoopy Baby/Infant Cotton Hooded Bath Towel - White
$29.99
Skip Hop Moby All-In-One Elbow Saver & Kneeler - Grey
$39.99
Wants: 2
Carter's 6-Pack Organic Cotton Washcloths - Light Cream
$14.00
Carter's Hooded Towel (2 Pack) - Cream, O/S
$16.99 Was $26.00
Frida Baby 4-in-1 Grow With Me Bath Tub & Rinse Cup Bundle
Still needs $65.98
Dreambaby Room and Bath Thermometer - Duck
$14.98 Was $14.99
Nursery & Decor
Wants: 3
BILLY Bookcase - black oak effect 31 1/2x11x79 1/2 "
$79.00
BILLY Bookcase - black oak effect 15 3/4x11x79 1/2 "
$49.00
Wants: 2
BILLY Bookcase corner comb w ext units - black oak effect 53 1/2/53 1/2x11x93 1/4 "
$305.00
Sofa Rocking Chair Metal Frame with Adjustable Backrest Comfortable Decorative Chair Modern Ergonomic Sofa for Living Room Bedroom
$139.00
Peanuts Snoopy Music is Best Shared Framed Wood Wall Decor - Fun Snoopy Picture for Music Room or Classroom
$34.99
Lambs & Ivy Snoopy Plush Dog Stuffed Animal
$18.39
Lambs & Ivy Snoopy Milestone Photo Opportunity Black/White Fleece Baby Blanket
$39.99
Peanuts Gang Baseball Celebration Framed Wood Wall Decor - Cute Peanuts Baseball Picture for Kids' Bedroom or Play Room
$34.99
Peanuts Snoopy and Woodstock I Love You More Framed Wood Wall Decor - Adorable Snoopy Picture for Home Decorating
$31.99
Bedtime Originals Snoopy Love Musical Baby Crib Mobile Soother Toy
$49.99
Lambs & Ivy Night Light Table Lamp - Snoopy
$49.99
Clothing
Small Story High-Pile Fleece Bunting - Oat, Newborn
$39.99
Small Story High-Pile Fleece Bunting - Grey, 0-3 M
$39.99
Small Story 4 Pack Mittens - White, 0-6 M
$12.99
Huggies Gripper Socks (12 Pack) - White, 0-6 M
$18.00
Zutano Cozie Fleece Hat - Heather Grey, 0-3 M
$15.00
Burt's Bees Baby Quilted Bee Booties - Oat, 0-3 M
$16.95
Burt's Bees Baby Quilted Bee Booties - Heather Grey, 0-3 M
$17.95
Snoopy Peanuts Woodstock Newborn Baby Boys Cozy Faux Sherling Zip Up Cosplay Coverall White Newborn
$26.99
Playing
Wants: 2
24 Pack Baby Teether Rings Links Toys Colorful Round Connecting Ring for Rattle Strollers Car Seat Travel Toys - Suit for Baby, Infant, Newborn, Kids(Rainbow Colors)
$9.87
Most wantedGraco Pack 'n Play Close2Baby Playard - Derby
Still needs $219.99
Magnetic Big Alphabet ABC Flash Cards - 52 Sturdy Uppercase & Lowercase Large Letters, Black - for Classroom Teachers, Homeschool, ESL, Kids and Adults
$23.25
Wants: 2
Pack and Play Sheets, 2 Pack Mini Crib Sheets, Stretchy Playard Fitted Sheet, Compatible with Graco Pack n Play, Soft and Breathable Material, Grey & White
$16.99
54 PCS Magnetic Blocks, Magnetic Building Blocks for Toddlers 3+, Montessori Toys, Magnet Cubes, Preschool STEM Educational Sensory Magnet Toys for Kids Ages 3-5 Year Old Boys and Girls
$24.58
Radio Flyer Classic Push & Play Walker
radioflyer Icon
$69.99
Penguin Random House Baby's Tummy Time
Book Box Set: A 3-Book Box Set
$39.95
Babylist Classic Picture Books Bundle
$27.97
Lovevery The Play Gym
Still needs $165.00
Montessori Wooden Busy Board - Sensory Toys for Toddlers Fine Motor Skills - Activity Board Toys for Kids - Educational Fidget Travel Toys for Baby Boy & Girl - Birthday Gifts for 1 2 3 4 + years old
$29.99
Moonkie Stacking Cups Toy, Fun Educational Baby Toys Silicone Soft Teething Toy, Age 6+ Months, 7 Piece Set
$13.99
Kids Preferred Peanuts Plush and Sensory Crinkle Teether Toys for Newborn Baby Boys and Girls with On-The-Go Clip for Stroller and Car Seat, 10.5 inches
$8.00
Kids Preferred Peanuts Snoopy Baby Stuff Fun Crinkle Book with On The Go Travel Clip Teether Soft Sensory Book for Babies & Toddlers, 5.x5.5 Inches
$11.00
KIDS PREFERRED Peanuts Snoopy Baby Sensory Toy Crinkle Blanket Stuffed Animal for Newborn Infants and Babies Teether Toys with Stroller Car Seat Loop
$9.99
Most wantedIngenuity Keep Cozy 3-in-1 Grow with Me Vibrating Baby Bouncer Seat & Infant to Toddler Rocker, Vibrations & Toy Bar, 0-30 Months Up to 40 lbs (Linden)
$59.99
Help & Favors
Used Baby Clothes
Baby Books
For the Parent(s)
Dapple Breast Pump Cleaning Wipes (3 Pack) - Pink, Fragrance-Free, 25
$17.99
Frida Mom Upside Down Peri Bottle Sprayer, Perineal Care & Postpartum Recovery, Portable Travel Bidet & Perineal Cleanser with Travel Bag, Postpartum Essential, Gray
$12.97
MOON PARK Pregnancy Pillows for Sleeping - U Shaped Full Body Maternity Pillow with Removable Cover - Support for Back, Legs, Belly, HIPS - 57 Inch - Black - Cooling Cover
$47.58
Always Discreet Overnight Adult Incontinence & Postpartum Bladder Leak Underwear for Women, Disposable, Small/Medium, 48 Count (3 Packs of 16)
$49.95
Postpartum Cold Pack, Perineal Cooling Pad Pregnancy & Hemorrhoid Pain Relief, Postpartum Ice Pack Pads with 2 Washable Sleeves (Blue (4 ice Pack+2 Fabric Cover))
$11.99
HOFISH 3PACK Full Bust Seamless Nursing Maternity Bras Bralette S-XXL with Extra Bra Extenders & Clips
$24.09
Suekaphin 5pack Nursing Bra Maternity Bra Breastfeeding Sleeping/Sleep Bra Pregnancy Women's Seamless Bralette Wirefree
$38.99
Womens Maternity Nursing Tank Cami for Breastfeeding with Adjustable Straps
$32.99
ChongErfei Maternity Belt, Pregnancy 3 in 1 Support Belt for Back/Pelvic/Hip Pain, Maternity Band Belly Support for Pregnancy Belly Support Band (M: Fit Ab 35.5"-47.3", Black)
$19.99
3 in 1 Postpartum Belly Band - Postpartum Belly Support Recovery Wrap, After Birth Brace, Slimming Girdles, Body Shaper Waist Shapewear, Post Surgery Pregnancy Belly Support Band (S/M, Black)
$25.99
Cash & Gift Cards
Babylist Shop Gift Card
From $25 to $1,000
Babylist Parental Leave Fund
Any amount
Cash or check (in person or by mail)
Wants: Unlimited
Uber - Gift Cards
gifts Icon
$50.00
Wants: Unlimited
Instacart Instacart Gift Card - 100
instacart Icon
$100.00
