Baby Squiggles Keefer
Nicole Cyrier Keefer & William Keefer
Plainfield, IL
November 1, 2025
We're excited and totally unsure of what to expect! Please help us choose items that we may have overlooked. Also, we're seeking more natural options, such as avoiding plastic and opting for materials like glass, metals, wood, cotton, and similar fibers. Thank you! ♡
NOTE: We are open to anything on this list from Rebel.com, GoodBuyGear.com, or any other source that offers 'open-boxed' items. I am uncertain about previously used items, as it may be difficult to completely clean everything before using the gift. Again, we are INCREDIBLY GRATEFUL!!!Most wanted
Most wantedLittle Park Ranger Baby Board Book Set
uncommongoods Icon
$17.00
Most wantedPIPA™ Aire RX + PIPA Relx Base Infant Car Seat
$650.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedNuna PIPA adapter for UPPABaby Vista and Cruz
$75.00
Most wantedSilk Head Support
usa Icon
$63.75
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedNuna Pipa RELX Infant Car Seat Base
$250.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedBlowout Blockerz Jams
bucklemecoats Icon
$34.99
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedBlowout Blockerz Jams
bucklemecoats Icon
$34.99
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedBuckle Me Baby Coziest Car Seat Blankie
bucklemecoats Icon
$39.99
Most wantedBevvy™ - UPPAbaby
$99.99
uppababy Icon
from $99.00
Most wantedNewborn Feeding Gift Set（0+ month~6+ month )(Not Glass) – Pigeon
pigeonstore Icon
$55.99
Most wantedLatchLight LP – shoplatchlight.com
shoplatchlight Icon
$34.99
Most wantedUpseat Baby Floor & Booster Seat with Tray - Coconut
$119.99
Wants: 2
Most wantedReusable Silicone Breastmilk Bags for Breastfeeding
momcozy Icon
$41.99
Most wantedNatural Cocoon+
weareamma Icon
$99.00
Wants: 4
Most wantedTHE CANTEEN
boobcube Icon
$21.99
Most wantedNatural Cocoon+
weareamma Icon
$99.00
Wants: 2
Most wantedTHE FIRST DROP KIT
boobcube Icon
$59.99
Most wantedMomcozy KleanPal Pro Baby Bottle Washer and Sterilizer
$299.99
Most wantedComfortCloud Crib Mattress
organic-dream Icon
$245.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedMini Crib Mattress - Mini / White
$199.99
newtonbaby Icon
from $199.99
Most wantedTwin/Full-Size Bed Conversion Kit (M5789)
$129.00
babyletto Icon
from $119.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedRolli All-Stages® Midi Crib Conversion Kit
$169.00
babyletto Icon
from $169.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedRolli 9-in-1 Convertible All-Stages® Crib with Bassinet & Toddler Bed Conversion Kits
$599.00
babyletto Icon
from $599.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedNewton Baby Breathable 2-Stage Crib Mattress - White
Still needs $329.99
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedNanit Pro Smart Baby Monitor and Floor Stand - White
$399.99
Most wantedEveryLife Diapers & Wipes Bundle
everylife Icon
$87.99
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedWillow
papercliplife Icon
$199.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedChicco Float Baby Bouncer Seat - Cloud
$169.99
Most wantedInfant Lounger | Honey
snugglemeorganic Icon
$129.99
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedBÉIS 'The Ultimate Diaper Backpack' in Atlas Pink - Best Pink Backpack Diaper Bag
beistravel Icon
$198.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedCotton Muslin Car Seat Canopy - Taupe Cross
littleunicorn Icon
$39.99
Most wantedBuy Alpine Muffy Baby | Hearing protection for babies
alpinehearingprotection Icon
$29.70
Most wantedLifeVac Home Kit
$79.95
Most wantedBath Filter for Baby | The Best Bathtub Water Filter - Canopy
getcanopy Icon
$89.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wanted15 In. Cuddle Buddies Gift Set with Bunny Blanket – Vermont Teddy Bear
vermontteddybear Icon
$92.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedDisney | Magnetic Me moments with friends modal convertible grow with
magneticme Icon
$44.00
Most wantedbig love modal magnetic grow with me convertible coverall – Magnetic Me
magneticme Icon
$40.00
Most wantedMontessori Wooden Baby Walker, Educational Push Toy, Activity Walker with Shapes and Numbers, Baby’s First Steps Gift
$150.00
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedDad's Bonding Shirt
jeroble Icon
$99.95
Note from Nicole and William:
Most wantedLayers of Love Family Handprint Kit
uncommongoods Icon
$30.00
Most wantedFrida Mom Motherloaded Hospital Bag Kit - White
$199.99
Books
Penguin Random House I Love You to the Moon and Back
$18.99
HarperCollins If You Give a Mouse a Cookie
$19.99
Penguin Random House The Snowy Day
$8.99
Babylist Classic Picture Books Bundle
$27.97
Penguin Random House Make Way for Ducklings
$19.99
Explore the Four Seasons Pop-Up Books
uncommongoods Icon
$37.00
Future Foodie Board Book Set
uncommongoods Icon
$33.00
Most wantedLittle Park Ranger Baby Board Book Set
uncommongoods Icon
$17.00
If I Were A Kitten Jellycat Board Book
pencieandginger Icon
$15.00
Wee Gallery: Peek-a-boo Ocean
weegallery Icon
$18.95
Wee Gallery Touch and Feel: Tails
weegallery Icon
$13.99
On Noah's Ark
$15.34
Carriers/transport
CozyHandmuffs - Jake
$49.99
UPPAbaby RIDGE Performance Rain Shield
$59.99
Nuna PIPA series Winter Footmuff - Caviar
$100.00
Nuna PIPA series Raincover
$50.00
Out of stock
Most wantedPIPA™ Aire RX + PIPA Relx Base Infant Car Seat
$650.00
Most wantedNuna PIPA adapter for UPPABaby Vista and Cruz
$75.00
Most wantedSilk Head Support
usa Icon
$63.75
UPPAbaby CozyGanoosh - Callum/Dillan
$199.99
Most wantedNuna Pipa RELX Infant Car Seat Base
$250.00
Universal Pram Liner - FARM
wonderland4children Icon
$64.95
RIDGE Parent Console Stroller Organizer
$59.99
UPPAbaby RIDGE Snack Tray
$54.99
Most wantedBlowout Blockerz Jams
bucklemecoats Icon
$34.99
Most wantedBlowout Blockerz Jams
bucklemecoats Icon
$34.99
Most wantedBuckle Me Baby Coziest Car Seat Blankie
bucklemecoats Icon
$39.99
PiggyBack for Vista - UPPAbaby
$179.99
uppababy Icon
from $179.00
Most wantedBevvy™ - UPPAbaby
$99.99
uppababy Icon
from $99.00
Other Baby Registries
Etsy Baby Registry
Target Baby Registry
Amazon Baby Registry
Feeding
Yellow Holy Spirit Silicone Grace Placemat
shininglightdolls Icon
$9.99
Wants: 2
Miss Mouth\'s Messy Eater Stain Treater Spray (3-Pack)
$22.49
Stainless Steel Snack Cups
elkandfriends Icon
$19.99
Most wantedNewborn Feeding Gift Set（0+ month~6+ month )(Not Glass) – Pigeon
pigeonstore Icon
$55.99
Babymoov Cloudnest Organic Anti-Colic Baby Lounger
$89.99
Out of stock
Most wantedLatchLight LP – shoplatchlight.com
shoplatchlight Icon
$34.99
Most wantedUpseat Baby Floor & Booster Seat with Tray - Coconut
$119.99
Wants: 2
Most wantedReusable Silicone Breastmilk Bags for Breastfeeding
momcozy Icon
$41.99
Most wantedNatural Cocoon+
weareamma Icon
$99.00
Wants: 4
Most wantedTHE CANTEEN
boobcube Icon
$21.99
Wants: 2
Evenflo Balance Wide-Neck Anti-Colic Baby Bottles - 9oz/2pk
$9.97
Cotton Muslin Burp Cloth - Party Animals
littleunicorn Icon
$7.00
Cotton Muslin + Fleece Bandana Bib 4 Pack - Tropical Leaf
littleunicorn Icon
$10.00
Cotton Muslin Burp Cloth 2 Pack - Adobe Checker
littleunicorn Icon
$20.00
Most wantedNatural Cocoon+
weareamma Icon
$99.00
Tiny Kind Burp Cloth 4 Pack - Bunny Hop
$30.00
Wants: 2
Most wantedTHE FIRST DROP KIT
boobcube Icon
$59.99
Most wantedMomcozy KleanPal Pro Baby Bottle Washer and Sterilizer
$299.99
Beaba On-The-Go Meal Set - Rain
$74.95
Out of stock
Momcozy Upgraded Adjustable Nursing Pillow
$54.99
Stokke Tripp Trapp Classic Cushion² - Wheat Cream
$69.00
Stokke Tripp Trapp Classic Cushion² - Terrocata
$69.00
Sleeping
Finley's Fawn Blanket
cadenlane Icon
$58.00
Finley's Fawn Crib Sheet
cadenlane Icon
$40.00
Most wantedComfortCloud Crib Mattress
organic-dream Icon
$245.00
Most wantedMini Crib Mattress - Mini / White
$199.99
newtonbaby Icon
from $199.99
Most wantedTwin/Full-Size Bed Conversion Kit (M5789)
$129.00
babyletto Icon
from $119.00
Most wantedRolli All-Stages® Midi Crib Conversion Kit
$169.00
babyletto Icon
from $169.00
Most wantedRolli 9-in-1 Convertible All-Stages® Crib with Bassinet & Toddler Bed Conversion Kits
$599.00
babyletto Icon
from $599.00
Kasa Smart Plug, 3 Count
$15.98
Fleece Sleep Everywhere Sack™
bucklemecoats Icon
$39.99
Tiny Kind Knotted Gown - Sage Leaf, 0-3 M
$24.00
Tiny Kind Wearable Blanket 0.3 TOG - Desert Sage, 0-6 M
$26.00
Fruit of the Spirit PJ Footless Onesie Bamboo – Holy Pals
holypals Icon
$32.00
babyletto Quilted Changing Pad Cover in GOTS Certified Organic Muslin Cotton - Olive Branches
$36.00
Tiny Kind Knotted Gown - Sage Leaf, 0-3 M
$24.00
Small Story Gown (2 Pack) - Crazy Dogs, 0-6 M
$23.99
Copper Pearl Printed Knotted Gown - Rad, 0-4 M
$18.87
Newton Baby Breathable 2-Stage Crib Mattress - White
$299.99
Owlet Owlet Monitor Duo: Smart Sock 3 & HD Camera (Android Only)
$399.00
Out of stock
Tiny Kind The Muslin Crib Sheet - Brush Strokes
$7.25
Out of stock
Tiny Kind Muslin Crib Sheet - Desert Sage
$29.00
Most wantedNewton Baby Breathable 2-Stage Crib Mattress - White
Still needs $329.99
Most wantedNanit Pro Smart Baby Monitor and Floor Stand - White
$399.99
Tiny Kind Muslin Swaddle (3 Pack) - Multi Leaf Sage
$38.00
Out of stock
Owlet Dream Duo 2 Smart Baby Monitor - Mint
$349.99
Nanit Travel Case - Sage
$29.99
nanit Icon
from $29.99
Nanit Nanit Smart Baby Monitor Multi-Stand Accessory
$49.99
Diapering
Most wantedEveryLife Diapers & Wipes Bundle
everylife Icon
$87.99
Skip Hop Light-Up Diaper Caddy - Oat
$44.99
Terra Pure Water Baby Wipes (840 Pack) - 840
$79.99
Out of stock
Esembly Wipe Ups
$13.99 Was $14.00
Baby Gear
Totes Babies Car Seat Carrier
totesbabies Icon
$54.95
Peekaboo Pillow | Original
peekaboopillow Icon
$149.00
Most wantedWillow
papercliplife Icon
$199.00
Most wantedChicco Float Baby Bouncer Seat - Cloud
$169.99
Most wantedInfant Lounger | Honey
snugglemeorganic Icon
$129.99
Skip Hop Stroll & Connect Stroller Fan - Charcoal
$19.99
Momcozy USB Rechargeable Handheld Cooling Fan for Travel - Sage Green
$29.99
Wants: 2
UPPAbaby RIDGE Cup Holder
$24.99
Most wantedBÉIS 'The Ultimate Diaper Backpack' in Atlas Pink - Best Pink Backpack Diaper Bag
beistravel Icon
$198.00
Lotus Adventure & Travel Set – Guava Family
guavafamily Icon
$299.00
Babymoov Aquani 3-in-1 Anti-UV Play Area - Marine
$99.99
Boppy Preferred Shopping Cart Cover - Paintbox
$44.99
Babymoov Lovenest Organic Infant Headrest - Smokey
$24.99
babymoov Icon
from $21.99
Most wantedCotton Muslin Car Seat Canopy - Taupe Cross
littleunicorn Icon
$39.99
BabyBjörn Winter Cover for Baby Carrier
$99.99
UPPAbaby CozyHandmuffs - Callum/Dillan
$59.99
UPPAbaby Performance Rain Shield for VISTA, VISTA 2, VISTA 3, CRUZ & CRUZ V2
$59.99
Nuna TRVL Easy Fold Compact Stroller Raincover
$49.95
UPPAbaby RumbleSeat/Bassinet Travel Bag
$89.99
Health & Safety
Most wantedBuy Alpine Muffy Baby | Hearing protection for babies
alpinehearingprotection Icon
$29.70
Oogiebear Baby Booger Picker - Single
$9.99
ezpz Baby-Led Toothbrush - Sage
$8.99
Braun ThermoScan7 Ear Thermometer
$74.99
GROWNSY Electric Nasal Aspirator with 3 Silicone Tips
$39.99
Babylist Baby First Aid & Grooming Kit
$69.99
AEIOU Silicone & Wood Multi-Ring Teether - Oat Milk
$20.00
Frida Baby 3-in-1 True Temp Thermometer
$19.99
Frida Baby 3-in-1 True Temp Thermometer
$19.99
Momcozy Momcozy 360 Silicone Baby Toothbrush, Toddler Toothbrush - Pink
$9.99
Most wantedLifeVac Home Kit
$79.95
Bathing
Most wantedBath Filter for Baby | The Best Bathtub Water Filter - Canopy
getcanopy Icon
$89.00
Calendula Baby Oil
$14.99
Motherlove Birth & Baby Oil - 2 Oz
$12.99
Tiny Kind Organic Bath and Towel Spa 4 Piece Set - Antique White, 0-24 M
$47.00
Lalo The Organic Washcloth 3-pack - Coconut
meetlalo Icon
$15.99
Lalo Elbow & Knee Saver - Sage
$37.99
meetlalo Icon
from $37.99
Tiny Kind Organic Bath and Towel Spa 4 Piece Set - Desert Sage/Antique White, 0-24 M
$48.00
Tiny Kind Cozy Critter Organic Bath Time Set 4 Piece - Taupe Bear, 0-24 M
$55.00
Nursery & Decor
Gift Set without Cactus Feeder/Teether
uncommongoods Icon
$55.00
Most wanted15 In. Cuddle Buddies Gift Set with Bunny Blanket – Vermont Teddy Bear
vermontteddybear Icon
$92.00
Barefoot Dreams CozyChic ABC Stroller Blanket - Cream/Beach Rock
$77.99
Sprucely Drawer Dividers - Bright White, 2 Pack
$16.99
Duck Nursery Decor, Needle Felted Duck, Handmade Baby Shower Gift, Embroidery Hoop Wall Art, Baby Shower Ideas, Duck nursery theme
$37.98
Clothing
Baby Bundle Footie - Avocado + Mint Twist – Bonsie Skin to Skin Babywear
bonsie Icon
$72.18
Made In America Graphic Bodysuit | White
cadenlane Icon
$24.00
Most wantedDisney | Magnetic Me moments with friends modal convertible grow with
magneticme Icon
$44.00
Most wantedbig love modal magnetic grow with me convertible coverall – Magnetic Me
magneticme Icon
$40.00
Wants: 3
THE LOOPBODY
petit-cochon Icon
$44.00
Goumi Kids Stay-On Baby Mitts (3 Pack) - Moss + Terrazzo + Sandstone, 0-3 M
$30.00
Tiny Kind The Head to Toe 7 Piece Set - Sage Multi Leaf, 0-3 M
$98.00
Tiny Kind Bamboo 6-Pack Socks - Ecru, 0-3 M
$32.00
Tiny Kind The Waffle 3-Piece Set - Lt. Olive, 0-3 M
$19.60
Out of stock
Playing
Catholic ABC Alphabet Blocks
shininglightdolls Icon
$34.99
b is for ball® - 3-Ball Set | Montessori-Inspired "L" Shaped Box
biggestlittlebk Icon
$36.00
Unique Rosary Catholic perfect gift for baby baptism gift for children rosaries Catholic gift for baby shower rainbow abacus First Communion
$39.09
Wooden Number Building Block – KidsGiftsStuff
kidsgiftsstuff Icon
$24.99
Natural Connections & Discovery Game
uncommongoods Icon
$35.00
American Sign Language Blocks
uncommongoods Icon
$48.00
Toddler Squishy Sensory Blocks Set
uncommongoods Icon
$35.00
Throw & Go Magnetic Wooden Travel Blocks
uncommongoods Icon
$30.00
🎁Summer Vacation Pre-sale 49%OFF - Wooden Animal Pattern Alphabet Learning Toy
economicalh Icon
$33.00
Animal Wooden Puzzles for Toddlers - Colors and Counting Building Toys and Toddler Games - Montessori Toys Wood Blocks
$24.79
AEIOU Silicone & Wood Multi-Ring Teether - Sky Multi
$20.00
Loomsake Wooden Alphabet Blocks - Rust
$69.00
Melissa & Doug Wooden Toy Essentials Bundle
$43.99 Was $45.98
Janod Alphabet Puzzle
$35.99
Rainbow Music Tree Wooden Petals Assembly and Marble Run Balls
bestwoodengifts Icon
$109.99
Crinkle Plush Goose
coloredorganics Icon
$29.00
Pilla Duckling
steiff Icon
$32.00
Lambs & Ivy Interactive Plush Toy with Animals - Baby Noah
$34.99
Xylophone - Montessori Toys Baby Gifts - Aesthetic & Functional Kids Musical Instrument – Modern Boho Xylophone for Kids - Wooden Xylophone
$25.19
Most wantedMontessori Wooden Baby Walker, Educational Push Toy, Activity Walker with Shapes and Numbers, Baby’s First Steps Gift
$150.00
Personalized Muslin Goose - Newborn Sleep Companion, Hypoallergenic Toy , Baby Shower Gift,,Customer doll,Linen Goose Toy,Baby shower custom
$45.75
Wooden Human Anatomy Puzzle, Kids Montessori Learning Set, Educational Birthday Gift, Montessori Toy
$20.65
1st Easter Name Puzzle First Birthday Gift Newborn gift Boy Custom Busy Board for Kids 1 year old
$37.85
Custom Handmade Name Puzzle with Animals, Personalized Birthday Gift for Kids, Christmas Gifts for Toddlers, Unique New Baby Gift, Wood Toy
$38.40
Taggies Soft Book - Buddy Dog
$18.99
Lovevery Hide & Find Drop Box, Baby Toy - 9 Months+
$27.00
Lovevery The Sensory Strands
$25.00
lovevery Icon
from $25.00
Lovevery The Play Kits (3-Kit Gift)
$228.00 Was $240.00
lovevery Icon
from $228.00
Lovevery The Block Set - 70pc
$95.00
lovevery Icon
from $90.00
Lovevery The Play Gym
$150.00
lovevery Icon
from $150.00
Wheel Reflectors for VISTA and VISTA V2 (Set of 4)
$22.99
Hape Montessori Peg Puzzle
$24.99
Hape Pound and Tap Bench
$39.99
Melissa & Doug Shape Sorting Cube Classic Toy
$20.99
Etta Loves Wooden Puzzle Board - Etta Loves X Walala Studio
$25.00
Lalo The Play Box - 0-12 Weeks
$95.00
meetlalo Icon
from $95.00
General
Bonobo Baby Bidet
bonobobaby Icon
$15.99
It Takes a Village (Help & Favors)
Used Baby Clothes
Home-Cooked Meal
Blank Coupon
For the Parent(s)
Most wantedDad's Bonding Shirt
jeroble Icon
$99.95
Most wantedLayers of Love Family Handprint Kit
uncommongoods Icon
$30.00
Earth Mama Organic Perineal Balm - 2 Fl Oz
$15.49 Was $15.99
Earth Mama Herbal Perineal Spray - 4 Fl Oz
$13.99
Frida Mom Perineal Cooling Comfort Cushion
$39.99
Lansinoh Postpartum Recovery Essentials
$34.99 Was $39.99
lansinoh Icon
from $33.00
Frida Mom Delivery and Nursing Gown
$29.99
Most wantedFrida Mom Motherloaded Hospital Bag Kit - White
$199.99
Wants: 2
Lansinoh Stay Dry Disposable Nursing Pads - 200
$18.99 Was $24.99
Lansinoh Hot & Cold Breast Therapy Packs
$11.97 Was $14.99
lansinoh Icon
from $8.65
Motherlove Nipple Cream - 1 Oz
$12.99
GROWNSY All-in-One Postpartum Essentials Kit
$36.99
Frida Mom C-Section Kit
$99.99
Pregnant Girl Summer Shirt, Comfort Colors Beach Pregnancy Announcement T-shirt, Pregnancy Reveal Tee, Baby Shower Gift, Mom Shirt
$20.99
Cash & Gift Cards
Babylist Shop Gift Card
From $25 to $1,000
Purchased
Purchased
Penguin Random House Madeline
Purchased
BabyBjörn Baby Carrier Free - Grey
Purchased
Infant SnugSeat - UPPAbaby
Purchased
JolyWell Egg Light for Nursery
Purchased
Stokke Registry
Purchased
UPPAbaby Vista V3 Stroller - Callum
Purchased
Babymoov Anti-UV Tent - Blue Waves
Purchased
Stokke Tripp Trapp Newborn Set - Grey
Purchased
Lansinoh Bottles - 5 Oz
Purchased
Lalo Bathtime Essential Accessories Bundle - Coconut
Purchased
Frida Baby Soft Sink Baby Bath
Purchased
Lansinoh Bottles - 8 Oz
Purchased
Carry-All Parent Organizer - UPPAbaby
Purchased
Pillow - Storytime Pooh
Purchased
Dreambaby Room and Bath Thermometer - Duck
Purchased
Fravita Handy Night Light
Purchased
Munchkin Touch Free Baby Wipe Warmer with Nightlight
Purchased
Macmillan Publishers Night Night Little One
Purchased
Macmillan See, Touch, Feel: ABC
Purchased
Macmillan Night Night Farm
Purchased
Dreambaby Strollerbuddy Strollaway Over The Door Stroller Hanger
Purchased
Fisher-Price Wooden Interlocking Blocks
Purchased
Future Pasta Fan Baby Gift Set
