Tesla and Matthew’s Baby Registry
Tesla Phelinger & Matthew Baumgartner
Columbus, OH
June 3, 2026
Hi everyone! 🤍
We’re so excited to welcome our baby boy and are incredibly grateful for all the love and support already surrounding him.
This registry is a mix of things we’ll truly need and a few extras we’d appreciate but can go without. To make things easier (and take the guesswork out), I’ve added a star system to show how important each item is to us:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — Very needed / top priority
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — Essentials
⭐️⭐️⭐️ — Really helpful
⭐️⭐️ — Helpful
⭐️ — Still needed, just not urgent
No ⭐️ — Totally optional, but appreciated!
We are also open to secondhand on any items! (Facebook marketplace is a great resource!)
Please don’t feel any pressure at all—your love and support mean more than anything. We’re just so grateful you’re here to celebrate this sweet little boy with us. 🩵Bundled picks made to gift
Made with Babylist Shop items from their registry.
⭐️ Most wanted ⭐️
Most wantedHand Embroidery Sweaters, Custom Toddler Sweaters, Knit Sweater, Baby Jumper, Gifts for Daughters, Nursery Gifts, Baby Boy Gift, Baby Girl
etsy Icon
$20.00
Most wantedNewborn Name Blanket, baby name swaddle, first and middle name blanket, baby name swaddle, newborn swaddle and blanket, Name Swaddle for Boy
etsy Icon
$56.40
Most wantedNewborn Photos Cash Fund
Any amount
Venmo
Cash & Gift Cards
Maternity Photos Cash Fund
Any amount
Venmo
Feeding
Dr. Brown's Microwave Steam - for Baby Bottles, Nipples, Bottle Parts, Pacifiers, Teethers and Breast Pump Parts
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
target Icon
$19.99
Flange Sizing Kit 3 in 1 with 10PCS Flange Inserts 13/15/17/19/21mm, Silicone Flanges Insert Kit for 24mm Flange/Shield, Pumping Essentials Kit for Moms
amazon Icon
$9.99
Wants: 2
Small Story Organic Cotton Lap Shoulder Bib (4 Pack) - Grey
babylist Icon
$18.99
Dr. Brown's Fresh Firsts Silicone Feeder - Mint & Gray, 2
babylist Icon
$9.99
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $9.99
Most wantedYASHE Mini Fridge, 4 Liter/6 Cans Small Refrigerator for Skincare, 110V AC/ 12V DC Thermoelectric Cooler and Warmer for Drink Office Dorm Bedroom Car, White
amazon Icon
target Icon
$44.99
Wants: 4
Small Story Burp Cloth (4 Pack) - Neutral Bears
babylist Icon
$19.99
Inglesina Fast Table Chair - Black
babylist Icon
$63.20 Was $79.00
20% off
walmart Icon
nordstrom Icon
amazon Icon
+1
from $63.20
Babylist Bottle Box (5 Bottles)
babylist Icon
$29.99 Was $55.45
Silverette Silver Nursing Cups - Regular
babylist Icon
$69.99
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
from $68.99
Sleeping
Momcozy Noise Machine for Baby Sleeping with Night Light - White
babylist Icon
$39.99
target Icon
amazon Icon
from $39.99
SwaddleDesigns Omni Swaddle Sack with Arms Up Half-Length Sleeves and Mitten Cuffs - Heathered Jadeite, Small 6-14 Lbs (0-3 Months)
babylist Icon
$28.00
target Icon
amazon Icon
from $24.00
Diapering
Tubby Todd Tubby Todd x Babylist All Over Ointment - Fragrance-Free, 8 Oz
babylist Icon
$36.00
Wants: 5
GREEN SPROUTS Muslin Cloths (5 Pack) - Blueberry
babylist Icon
$10.99
amazon Icon
from $12.99
Baby Gear
Baby Lounger for Newborn - Snuggle Cozy Me Lounger | Breathable Soft Cotton, 0-24 Months Portable Playtime Baby Nest, Newborn Baby Essentials Gifts - Lake Green(1 Lounger + 1 Cover)
amazon Icon
$32.99
Health & Safety
LifeVac Home Kit
lifevac Icon
$69.99
60PCS Baby Tongue Cleaner & 1PCS Finger Toothbrush Infant Mouth Cleaner Newborn Gum Cleaner Disposable Infant Oral Clean Stick Dental Care for Baby Toddler
amazon Icon
$9.99
Dermoplast Pain, Burn & Itch Relief Spray for Minor Cuts, Burns and Bug Bites, 2.75 Oz (Packaging May Vary)
babylist Icon
$10.65
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $7.74
Buy Alpine Muffy Baby | Hearing protection for babies
alpinehearingprotection Icon
$36.95
Frida Mom Postpartum Abdominal Support Binder - Grey
babylist Icon
$29.99
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $28.98
Safety 1st Home Safeguarding and Childproofing Set (80 Pcs), White
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
target Icon
$19.98
Mustela Newborn Baby Arrival Gift Set
nordstrom Icon
amazon Icon
$44.00
Mommy's Bliss Baby Organic Vitamin D Drops - 0.11oz (100 Servings)
amazon Icon
target Icon
walmart Icon
$12.49
Quark Thiingy Teething Ball
babylist Icon
$19.99
target Icon
from $14.99
Oogiebear 360 Teething Toothbrush
babylist Icon
$12.99
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $6.99
Little Remedies Gas Relief Drops - Simethicone
babylist Icon
$8.99 Was $9.99
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $7.66
Babylist Pacifier Box
babylist Icon
$26.99 Was $32.91
Frida Baby Windi Gas and Colic Reliever
babylist Icon
$15.99
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $10.99
Bathing
Tiikiy 1.5" Extra Thick Baby Bath Kneeler and Elbow Rest Set, Memory Foam Pad with 4 Organizer Pockets, Comfort Support for Bathing Baby & Pets - Gray Green
amazon Icon
$31.99
Dreambaby Room and Bath Thermometer - Turtle
babylist Icon
$14.99
walmart Icon
target Icon
from $14.98
Nursery & Decor
DIMJ Drawer Organizer Clothes Storage - 18 Pack Baby Dresser Organizer for Nursery, Foldable Closet Drawer Organizer Bins for Bedroom Organization, Fabric Storage Dividers for Socks, Underwears, Bras
amazon Icon
$22.99
Humble Crew 4-Tier Kids Bookshelf, Grey Wood/White - Premium Book Shelf for Kids Rooms with Four Deep Pockets - Toddler Sling Book Rack with Deep Sleeves, Nursery Bookcase Organizer
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
$22.65
Sprucely 8 Piece Closet Dividers - Grey
babylist Icon
$11.99
Clothing
Momcozy Hands Free Pumping Bra, Adjustable Breast-Pumps Holding and Nursing Bra, Pumping & Nursing Bra in One
amazon Icon
$19.99
BOOMIBOO 36 Pack Curtain Rings with Clips, Drapery Clips with Rings, Hangers Drapes Rings, Drapery Rings 1.26 inch, Fits up to 1 inch Diameter Curtain Rod, for Hanging Drapes Bows Hat and So On
amazon Icon
$6.99
Zeroest Newborn Photo Prop Stretch Knit Wrap for Baby Photography Newborn Photoshoot Outfits Boys Girls Posing Blanket (Soft Brown)
amazon Icon
$13.99
M&G House Newborn Photography Outfits Baby Crochet Knitted Photoshoot Props Animal Costume Set
amazon Icon
$21.99
Education
Chronicle Books Little Traveler Board Book Set
babylist Icon
$16.99
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $11.73
Hachette Book Group Be Kind Little One Board Book Set
babylist Icon
$14.99
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $10.99
The Noise Inside Boys: A Story About Big Feelings
amazon Icon
target Icon
$16.09
Penguin Random House Our Skin: A First Conversation About Race
babylist Icon
$14.99
amazon Icon
from $9.99
Penguin Random House Yes! No!: A First Conversation About Consent
babylist Icon
$14.99
amazon Icon
from $14.90
Penguin Random House Kindness Makes Us Strong
babylist Icon
$11.99
target Icon
from $7.36
Penguin Random House We're Different, We're the Same
babylist Icon
$9.99
amazon Icon
from $6.11
Alphabet Learning Pocket Chart, Alphabet Wall Chart for Toddlers 1-3, Handwriting Practice Letter Tracing Circle Time Learning Center for Classroom, Preschool Classroom Must Haves XL35x 27"
amazon Icon
$28.87
12 Calming Corner Classroom Posters (10x14) - Feelings Wheel Chart & Emotions Poster For Kids, Calm Down Corner Supplies For Therapy Office Decor, Mental Health Wall Decorations For Preschool
amazon Icon
$19.95
Hadley Designs 16 Educational Posters for Classroom Decor - Colorful Educational Posters for Toddlers 1-3, Toddler Learning Poster for Kids Ages 3-5, Kindergarten & Preschool Classroom Must Haves
amazon Icon
$24.99
General
Kate & Milo Baby Monthly Milestone Marker Discs - Classic Cursive Script Wooden Discs with Reversible Photo Props for Baby Announcement and Milestones, Gender-Neutral Gift for Newborn Boy and Girl
amazon Icon
$7.89
28 PCS Number Birthday Candles Champagne Number Candles Cake Candles for 1st Birthday to 18th Birthday Decoration, Wedding Anniversary, Party Celebration, Baby Showers (Champagne)
amazon Icon
$11.99
4-Pack Inkless Baby Hand and Footprint Kit - Mess Free Ink Pad for Newborn Keepsake, Dog Nose & Paw Print Kit, Clean Touch Ink Pad for Baby Hand & Footprints, Ideal New Mom Gifts (Jet Black)
amazon Icon
$12.96
Playing
Sassy Stacks of Circles Stem Toy
babylist Icon
$11.99
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
target Icon
from $9.96
Sassy Rainbow of Emotions Soft Activity Book
babylist Icon
$8.99
walmart Icon
target Icon
from $8.53
Other
LemonRoad 16x12x12inch Baby Memories Keepsake Box Baby Shower Elephant First Keepsake Box New Parent Newborn Baptismal Birthday Gift for Mementos Travel Loved Ones Treasured Keepsakes(Blue)
amazon Icon
$19.99
Purchased
Purchased
Hachette Book Group Pink Is For Boys
Purchased
It's Okay To Be Different (Todd Parr Classics)
Purchased
SWEET DOLPHIN 2-Pack Quilted Diaper Caddy Organizer – Premium Puffer Style Nursery Storage Bins – Water-Resistant & Wipeable Changing Table Organizer – Trendy Tote for Home & Car Travel - Mocha Brown
Purchased
GROWNSY Baby Food Maker with Steam Basket, One Step Baby Food Processor Steamer Puree Blender Grinder Mills Machine, Auto Cooking Grinding and Sterili-zing for Healthy Homemade Baby Food, BPA-Free
Purchased
Tummy Time Baby Mirror Infant Toys Newborn 0 3 Months Brain Development with Crinkle Cloth Book Teether Black and White High Contrast Baby Toys 2 4 5 0-6 Month Boys Girls Sensory Activity Shower Gifts
Purchased
Goovilla 3 Tier Rolling Utility Cart Organizer with Removable Drawer, Stable and Sturdy Black Rolling Storage Carts with 2 Lockable Wheels for Bathroom, Kitchen, Snack, Craft, Makeup, Baby Essentials
Purchased
Baby Trend EZ-Lift™ Plus Infant Car Seat Base, Black – Secure Click-in Attachment, Adjustable Recline Positions, Easy-Leveling Setup, Everyday Convenience for Growing Families
Purchased
Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump With Personalfit Flex
Purchased
Kidsneed Baby Monitor with Camera and Audio - 5 inch 720P Video Baby Monitor, No WiFi, 48H Battery Life, Night Vision, Two Way Talk, Remote Pan Tilt Zoom, Thermal Monitor，1000 ft Range（530）
Purchased
RUVALINO Diaper Bag Backpack-Multifunction Travel Baby Diaper Bag with Changing Pad, Insulated Bottle Holders & Pacifier Case, Large Capacity, Waterproof, Gray
Purchased
Coreeky Muslin Bedside Sleeper Bassinet Fitted Sheets, 3 Pack Cotton Baby Sheet for Boys & Girls, Soft, Compatible with Baby Delight, Dream On Me, AMKE and Other Rectangle Mattress (Leaf Green)
Purchased
Momcozy Portable Breast Milk Cooler - Green
Purchased
Tylenol Infant Dye-Free General Pain Reliever - Cherry - 1 fl oz
Purchased
My First Book of Baby Signs: 40 Essential Signs to Learn and Practice
Purchased
The First Years Spin Stack Drying Rack
Purchased
Itzy Ritzy Pacifier Clip - Toast
Purchased
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, 0-3 Months (4 Pack) - Green
Purchased
Baby Trend Stroller and EZ-Lift Infant Car Seat, EZ Ride Travel System, Dash Grey
Purchased
Ekouaer 3 in 1 Labor/Delivery/Hospital Gown Maternity Dress Nursing Nightgown Sleepwear for Breastfeeding
Purchased
HOFISH 3PACK Full Bust Seamless Nursing Maternity Bras Bralette S-XXL with Extra Bra Extenders & Clips
Purchased
Dr. Brown's Pacidose Medicine Dispenser, 0-6m, 6-18m
Purchased
Momcozy Baby Wrap Carrier
Purchased
Frida Baby 4-in-1 Grow With Me Bath Tub
Purchased
Owlet Dream Sock Smart Wearable Baby Monitor - Mint
Purchased
Munchkin Night Light In-Sight Pivot Car Back Seat Mirror
Purchased
Frida Baby Baby Basics Kit
Purchased
Frida Baby Electric Nail Buffer
Qty: 1
Purchased
Small Story Burp Cloth (4 Pack) - Neutral Bears
Purchased
Gaiatop Mini Portable Stroller Fan, Battery Operated Small Clip on, Detachable 3 Speed Rechargeable, 360° Rotate Flexible Tripod Better Cooling for Car Seat Crib Treadmill Travel Black
Purchased
Earth Mama Organic Nipple Butter - 2 fl oz
Purchased
Frida Baby 3-in-1 True Temp Thermometer
Purchased
Honest Baby Clothing 10-Pack Organic Cotton Baby Terry Wash Cloths - Rainbow Blues, Os
Purchased
JARLINK Toy Stuffed Animal Storage, Over The Door Organizer W/Clear View Windows, 44lb Load, Baby Toy Storage Organizer for Nursery, Kid Bedroom, Newborn Baby Essentials (Light Grey)
Purchased
Holikme Bottle Brush Tube Cleaning Lab Set with Long Handle, Cup Cleaner for Washing Narrow Neck Beer Wine Decanter Pipes Lids Sinks Cap Covers, White
