Bethany's Baby Registry
Bethany & Justin Mathews
Canastota, NY
October 21, 2025
Welcome to our baby registry! We are already so grateful for all of your support during this special time in our lives. If you’d like to purchase a gift, please find some suggestions below. We can’t wait for you to meet the newest member of our family soon! Please no newborn sizes.
Cleaning
Dapple Baby All Purpose Cleaning Spray, Hypoallergenic for Toys, High Chairs, Swings, Counters, Powered by Plants, 1 Pump Included, Fragrance Free, 16.9 Fl Oz (Pack of 2) + 30 Count Wipes
$22.97
Wants: Unlimited
Dreft Stage 1: Newborn Baby Liquid Laundry Detergent 114 loads 165 fl oz
$24.94
Stain Remover for Baby Clothes by Dreft, 24oz Pack of 2 Laundry Stain Remover Spray + To Go Instant Stain Remover Pen, Hypoallergenic, Great for Cloth Diapers
$19.99
Cash & Gift Cards
Wants: Unlimited
Instacart Instacart Gift Card - 25
instacart Icon
$25.00
Wants: Unlimited
DoorDash DoorDash Gift Card - 50
$15.00
Babylist Diaper Fund
Any amount
Venmo, Cash or check (in person or by mail)
Feeding
Dr. Brown's Wide-Neck Sippy Straw Bottle with Silicone Handles (2 Pack) - Gray & Pink, 9 Oz, 2
$16.99
3 PCS Dr Brown Glass Bottles Silicone Sleeves, Compatible with Dr Browns Glass Bottles 8 oz, Anti-Drop Dr Brown Baby Bottles Sleeves with Handles, Heat-Insulating and Easy to Clean
$7.99
Dr. Brown's Original Nipple, Level 3 (6m+), 6 Count
$10.99 Was $13.99
Stainless Steel Kids Plates Set of 4, 9" Portion Control Plates Divided Plate for Adults Toddlers Balance Lunch, Bariatric & Diabetic Diet, Non Toxic Camping Metal Snack Plate for Eating
$17.09
Konssy Muslin Nursing Cover for Baby Breastfeeding, Breathable 100% Cotton Breastfeeding Cover with Rigid Hoop for Mother Nursing Apron, Multi-use Carseat Canopy (Summer Wheat)
$11.99
Wants: Unlimited
Most wantedBaby Brezza Official Detergent Soap Tablets for Baby Brezza Bottle Washer Pro, 120 Tablets
$19.99
Most wantedBaby Brezza Descaler 8 oz. Made in USA. Universal Descaling Solution for Brezza and Other Baby Appliances. Removes Mineral Build-up and extends Your Machine’s lifespan (Pack of 2)
$25.98
Wants: Unlimited
Lansinoh Stay Dry Disposable Nursing Pads - 200
$18.99 Was $24.99
Sleeping
HALO Disney Sleepsack, 100% Cotton Wearable Blanket, Swaddle Transition Sleeping Bag, TOG 0.5, Winnie Frolic, Medium, 6-12 Months
$28.49
Aden + Anais Disney Essentials Cotton Muslin Swaddles (4 Pack) - Winnie + Friends, 4
$54.99
Lambs & Ivy Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet - Storytime Pooh
$29.99
Diapering
Ubbi Plastic Bags for Ubbi - 75
$19.99
Ubbi Lavender Scented Absorbing Gel Value Pack - 3 Count Diaper Pail Odor Control for Baby Nursery
$7.99
Millie Moon Luxury Disposable Diapers - Size 3 - 144ct
$39.99
BabyBjörn Potty Chair - Gray/White
$31.99
Wants: 2
Huggies Size 2 Diapers, Little Snugglers Baby Diapers, Size 2 (12-18 lbs), 180 Ct (3 packs of 60), Packaging May Vary
$52.66
Wants: 2
Huggies Size 3 Diapers, Little Movers Baby Diapers, Size 3 (16-28 lbs), 156 Count (6 packs of 26)
$31.01
Wants: 2
Disney Classic Pooh Hunny Fun with Piglet and Tigger White and Taupe Super Soft Changing Pad Cover
$21.99
Wants: Unlimited
Huggies Natural Care Sensitive Wipes - 768 Count
$21.67
Pampers Free and Gentle Wipes
$20.39
Baby Gear
Speedo Infant Life Vest - Teal/Coral
$34.99
POP 'N GO PLAYPEN - Indoor & Outdoor Baby Playpen for Babies and Toddlers - Baby Beach Tent, Foldable, Portable W/Canopy, Travel Bag, & Mosquito Net - Pop Up Pack and Play Tent (Black)
$119.99
Doona Sunshade Extension - Compatible with Doona Car Seat & Stroller
$48.00
Skip Hop Take Cover Shopping Cart Cover - Grey Feather
$27.99
Wants: 2
Most wantedGraco Turn2Me 3-in-1 Car Seat - Cambridge
$399.99
Health & Safety
Frida Baby Cool Pads, Fever Patch for Kids, Fever Reducer, Discomfort & Headache Relief, 5 Count
$5.49
Saline Nose Wipes by Boogie, for Baby & Kids, Face, Hand & Body, FSA/HSA Eligible, Made with Vitamin E, Aloe, and Natural Saline, Unscented, 30 Count (Pack of 3)
$12.47
Frida Baby 3-in-1 Ear, Forehead + Touchless Infrared Thermometer
$39.97 Was $39.99
Safety 1st Cabinet Slide Locks - 4pk
$6.99
Aveeno Baby Eczema Therapy Nighttime Moisturizing Balm, Soothes & Relieves Dry, Itchy Skin -11oz
$19.68
Mommy's Bliss Gripe Water Night Time, Infant Gas & Colic Relief, Gentle & Safe, 4 Weeks+, 4 FL OZ Bottle (Pack of 1)
$9.87
Babyganics 6oz Repellent Spray and 2oz Sunscreen Lotion Kit
$13.99
LifeVac Yellow Travel Kit - Portable Suction Rescue Device, First Aid Kit for Kids and Adults, Portable Airway Suction Device for Children and Adults
$79.99
Bathing
Yookidoo Baby Bath Shower Head - Elephant Water Pump and Trunk Spout Rinser - for Newborn Babies in Tub Or Sink
$24.95
Cetaphil Baby Healthy Skin Essentials Kit - 27 fl oz
$14.97
Frida Baby The 3-Step Cradle Cap System | DermaFrida The FlakeFixer | Sponge, Brush, Comb and Storage Stand for Babies with Cradle Cap
$16.99
Babyganics Hero Essentials Gift Set - 7ct
$27.99
Nursery & Decor
Toniebox Audio Player Starter Set with Playtime Puppy - Listen, Learn, and Play with One Huggable Little Box - Gray
$99.99
YGJT Kids Clothing Rack, Baby Clothes Rack for Hanging Clothes with Wheels and Bottom Storage Shelf, Small Toddler Garment Rack Kids Dress Up Storage Rack for Coats, Skirts, Dance Costume(White)
$29.99
OIAHOMY Large Blanket Basket, Rectangle Woven Baskets for Storage, Nursery Blanket Basket Living Room, Toy Basket With Handle, Large Baskets for Organizing-22”x17”x12”-Gradient Grey
$23.39
Your Baby's First Word Will Be DADA
$7.99
HarperCollins The Giving Tree
$19.99
Macmillan Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See?
$8.99
HarperCollins If You Give a Mouse a Cookie
$19.99
Wants: 2
Sprucely Drawer Dividers - Bright White, 2 Pack
$16.99
Clothing
HEYDUDE LILDUDE Slip-On Casual Shoe - Baby - Rose Gold | Journeys
journeys Icon
$34.99
Girls' Short Sleeve Puppy Bodysuit (Infant)
carhartt Icon
$8.99
MaxNova Baby Sun Hat Smile Face UPF 50+ Toddler Bucket Hat for Boys Girls 0-7 Years
$11.84
40 Pack Curtain Rings with Clips, Curtain Clip Rings Hooks, Bow Hanger Clips for Hanging Drapery Drapes Bows, Ring 1.26 inch Interior Diameter, Fits up to 1" Rod, Matte Silver
$12.99
Carhartt Baby Girls' Bib Overalls Lined and Unlined
$32.99
FIOMVA My First Christmas Baby Boy Girl Outfit Infant One Piece Jumpsuit Newborn Christmas Romper Fall Winter Clothes
$14.99
UGG Baby Bixbee Boot
$39.95
Burt's Bees Baby Quilted Bee Booties - Heather Grey, 3-6 M
$10.19
Burt's Bees Baby Quilted Bee Booties - Oat, 0-3 M
$19.95
Playing
![Catholic Baby's First Prayers [Hardcover] Bauer, Judith](https://images.babylist.com/image/upload/f_auto,q_auto:best,t_app_500px_square/jrxuwdovowde4kz8hhky.jpg)
Catholic Baby's First Prayers [Hardcover] Bauer, Judith
$12.28
Disney Winnie The Pooh White, Yellow, and Aqua Cloud and Sun Lovey Security Blanket
$22.00
Bumkins Disney Baby Silicone Undroppable Teething Mitt, Freezer Toy Teether Keys, Soft Flexible Platinum Silicone Pacifier to Chew, Cool Teether Gum Relief, Essential Babies 3 Months, Winnie The Pooh
$14.99
Vulli Sophie la Girafe
$31.99
Lucy Darling Camper Baby Teether Set, 2 Pcs Textured Silicone Teething Toys, 0+ Months Baby Essentials for Infant Girl or Boy, BPA-Free Teething Relief & Chew Toy, Easy to Hold, Chew & Clean Teethers
$29.99
Sassy Developmental Bumpy Ball
$14.99
Itsy Bitsy Spider - Children's Finger Puppet Board Book
$8.99
Baby Toys Crawling Crab - Infant Tummy Time Toys 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Baby Toys 6-12 12-18 Months Light-up Musical Walking Sensory Induction Crabs Interactive Toddler 1st Boys Girls Birthday Gifts
$14.99
Macmillan Publishers Night Night Little One
$9.99
The Wonderful Things You Will Be
$17.99
Skip Hop Bandana Buddies Puppy Stroller Toy
$16.99
General
Baby Memory Book/Large Keepsake Box & 30 Monthly & Baby First Milestone Stickers - Gender Neutral First Year Scrapbook Journal
$19.99
It Takes a Village (Help & Favors)
Wants: Unlimited
Home-Cooked Meal
Wants: Unlimited
Dog Walking
For the Parent(s)
Womens Maternity Nursing Tank Cami for Breastfeeding with Adjustable Straps
$32.99
Frida Mom Perineal Witch Hazel Cooling Pad Liners
$12.99
Frida Mom Disposable Postpartum Underwear for Women, Boyshort (8 Count)
$15.99
Willow Silver Nursing Nipple Shield Cups - 2pk
$31.99
Frida Mom Core Support Binder - Grey
$29.99
Purchased
Purchased
Doona Car Seat & Stroller, Greyhound - All-in-One Travel System
Purchased
4moms MamaRoo Multi-Motion Baby Swing, Bluetooth Enabled with 5 Unique Motions, Grey
Purchased
Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib and Changer with Drawer (Pebble Gray) – Crib and Changing Table Combo with Drawer, Includes Changing Pad, Converts to Toddler Bed, Daybed and Full-Size Bed
Purchased
Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress – GREENGUARD Gold Certified & CertiPUR-US Certified, Fits All Standard Crib & Toddler Beds, Waterproof Sleep Surface, Machine-Washable Outer Cover for Easy Care
Purchased
Disney Winnie the Pooh 3-Piece Crib Bedding Set, Gray, Comforter, Fitted Sheet, Blanket, Infant Boy or Girl
Purchased
Baby Ice Cream Short-Sleeve Cotton Romper - Pink - Carter's | Carter's
Purchased
New Parent Backpack 17L | Bags,Purses,Wallets | lululemon
Purchased
MUKIN Baby Washcloths - Soft Face Cloths for Newborn, Absorbent Bath Face Towels, Baby Wipes, Burp Cloths or Face Towels, Baby Registry as Shower. Pack of 6-12x12 inches (Grey)
Purchased
Skip Hop Baby Bath Spout Cover Universal Fit MOBY Grey
Purchased
Frida Baby Control The Flow Polypropylene ABS Rinser|Bath Time Rinse Cup with Easy Grip Handle and Removable Rain Shower
Purchased
Waterproof Quilted Bassinet Mattress Pad Cover Compatible with VaVaSoo, MMBABY, GoFirst, Milliard Bedside Bassinet, 2 Pack, Ultra Soft Viscose Made from Bamboo Terry Surface
Purchased
Baby Delight Beside Me Dreamer Bassinet And Bedside Sleeper - Charcoal
Purchased
Munchkin Sippy Cup for 6 Month Old and Up, Spill Proof Miracle 360 Toddler Cups with Transition Handles, 7 Ounce, 2 Pack, Pink/Purple
Purchased
Hatch Rest Baby Sound Machine, Night Light | 2nd Gen | Sleep Trainer, Time-to-Rise Alarm Clock, White Noise Soother, Music & Stories for Nursery, Toddler & Kids Bedroom (Wi-Fi)
Purchased
Diaper Rash Cream Spray by Boogie Bottoms, Travel Friendly No-Rub Touch Free Application for Sensitive Skin, from The Maker of Boogie Wipes, Over 200 Sprays per Bottle, 1.7 oz
Purchased
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Baby Diaper Rash Cream Maximum Strength - 4oz
Purchased
Frida Baby Not-too-cold-to-hold Teether - 3ct
Purchased
3 Pcs Baby Flower Headbands Baby Girls Nylon Headband Soft Hairbands Hair Accessories for Newborn Infant Toddler Kids (Beige Pink Khaki)
Purchased
Safety 1st Easy Grip Brush and Comb, Colors May Vary
Purchased
Dr. Brown’s Infant-to-Toddler Training Toothbrush Set with Fluoride-Free Baby Toothpaste, Strawberry - Giraffe - 1.4oz - 0-3 years
Purchased
Munchkin Stay Put Suction Bowls (3 Pack) - Purple/Green/Blue
Purchased
Munchkin Fresh Food Feeder, 2 Count (Pack of 1), Blue/Mint
Purchased
Bright Starts John Deere 4-in-1 Gator Green Baby Activity Center & Push Walker with Removable Interactive Steering Wheel Toy, 6 Months and up
Purchased
The Peanutshell Fitted Crib Sheets Set, Unisex 4 Pack Celestial Print, Grey Moon & Stars
Purchased
Disney Winnie The Pooh Classic Pooh Ivory, Sage, Butter Musical Mobile with Hunny Pot and Bees, Ivory, Sage, Butter, Brown
Purchased
Baby Delight Alpine Deluxe Portable Bouncer | Infant | 0 – 6 months | Charcoal Tweed
Purchased
Baby Brezza Electric Baby Bottle Warmer, Breastmilk Warmer + Defroster - Only Brand with Different Temperatures for Breastmilk + Formula - Universal Fit for All Baby Bottle Sizes + Breastmilk Bags
Purchased
Spark.Create.Imagine Woods Soft Cloth Baby Book, 0+
Purchased
The Honest Company Baby Gift Set
Purchased
Nuk 5 Fl Oz Disney Pooh Small Learner Cup
Purchased
Baby Nest, Baby Lounger, Organic Cotton Lounger for Baby, Reversible Breathable Adjustable Portable - Star Collection (Tan)
Purchased
Momcozy Insulated Baby Bottle Bag, Multi-Function Breastmilk Cooler Bag, Fits 6 Baby Bottles Up to 9oz, With Strap and PP Compartment, Baby Bottle Cooler Bag for Nursing Mom Daycare, Black
Qty: 2
Purchased
Shynerk Baby Car Mirror, 4.3'' HD Night Vision Function Car Mirror Display, Safety Car Seat Mirror Camera Monitored Mirror with Wide Crystal Clear View, Aimed at Baby, Easily Observe the Baby’s Move
Purchased
Sassy Stacks of Circles Stem Toy - Stacks Of Circles Stem Toy
Purchased
Itzy Ritzy Easy Hold Teether - Strawberry
Purchased
My First Bible Stories
Purchased
Car Seat Protector, 2 Pack Carseat Protector with Thick Padding, Baby/Pets for Child Car Seat-Mesh Pockets-Waterproof-Universal Size(Black)
Purchased
Sprucely Portable Stroller Fan
Purchased
Infinno Inflatable Tummy Time Mat Premium Baby Water Play Mat for Infants and Toddlers Baby Toys for 3 to 24 Months, Strengthen Your Baby's Muscles, Portable
Purchased
Lansinoh Sitz Bath Salts for Postpartum Recovery
Purchased
Palmer's Cocoa Butter Formula Massage Lotion For Stretch Marks, Pregnancy Skin Care, Belly Cream with Collagen, Elastin, Argan OIl and Shea Butter, 8.5 Ounces
Purchased
Emoin Dancing Cactus Baby Toys 6 to 12 Months, Talking Cactus Toys Repeats What You Say Baby Boy Toys, Dancing Cactus Mimicking Toy with LED English Sing Talking Musical Toys
Purchased
6 Pack Cotton Baby Burp Cloths Extra Absorbent Soft for Baby Boys and Girls (Multi02)
Purchased
GROWNSY Nasal Aspirator for Baby, Electric Nose Aspirator for Toddler, Baby Nose Sucker, Automatic Nose Cleaner with 3 Silicone Tips, Adjustable Suction Level, Music and Light Soothing Function
Purchased
Firefly Books Love You Forever
Purchased
FridaBaby NailFrida SnipperClipper Set
Purchased
Konssy Muslin Nursing Cover for Baby Breastfeeding, Breathable 100% Cotton Breastfeeding Cover with Rigid Hoop for Mother Nursing Apron, Multi-use Carseat Canopy (Sage)
Purchased
KeaBabies Suction Plates with Lids for Baby - 3-Pack 100% Silicone Toddler Plates with Suction, Divided, BPA-Free Baby Led Weaning Essentials for Kids, Dishwasher, Microwave Safe, Durable (Quantum)
Purchased
KeaBabies Silicone Baby Spoons, Self Feeding 6-12 months - 3-Pack Baby Weaning Eating Utensils, Toddler First Food Training Spoon, Infant, Kids Feeding Supplies Essential Set, Dishwasher-safe (Rocky)
Purchased
Neat Solutions Silicone "Loved Waffle Lot" Saying Infant Unisex Scoop Bib
Purchased
Babybjorn Baby Carrier Mini Jersey - Light Gray
Purchased
Hatch Rest Go | Portable Sound Machine for Babies and Kids | Sleep Soother | 10 Soothing Sounds | White Noise | Shush | Travel | Registry Gift | Baby Shower | Clips on Stroller | Putty
Purchased
Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail, Odor Locking, No Special Bag Required, Award-Winning, Registry Must-Have, White
Purchased
Lambs & Ivy Baby Blanket - Storytime Pooh
Purchased
Corduroy Big Board Book
Purchased
Graco FastAction Jogger LX Stroller - Drive, Convenient One-Hand Fold, Infant Car Seat Compatible, Ideal for Parents on The Go
Purchased
Baby Bath Seat for Babies 6 Months & up, Non-Slip Toddler Bath Seat for Baby & Newborn, Sit Up Bath Seat for Baby,Grey
Purchased
DOONA Snap-On Storage - Compatible Car Seat & Stroller
Purchased
Boon Lawn Countertop Drying Rack - Grey/White
Purchased
Munchkin Warm Glow Baby Wipe Warmer, White
Purchased
Itzy Ritzy Pop & Whirl – Fidget Spinner Travel & Bath Toy for Babies & Toddlers – Fidget w/Textured Silicone Popper to Develop Fine Motor Skills –Sticks to Highchairs, Tables, Tubs, More (Strawberry)
Purchased
Tommee Tippee UltraLight Stay Put Silicone Pacifier 6-18m - Pink & Purple - 2pk
Purchased
Dr. Brown's Pacifier and Bottle Wipes, 40 Count
Purchased
Munchkin® Wild™ Animal Baby and Toddler Bath Toy Squirts, 8 Pack
Purchased
Aquaphor Baby Welcome Baby Gift Set - Free WaterWipes and Bag Included - Healing Ointment, Wash and Shampoo, 3 in 1 Diaper Rash Cream
Purchased
b&h Baby Thermometer, The Infant Baby Bath Floating Toy Safety Temperature Water Thermometer (Classic Duck)
Purchased
Momcozy Universal Stroller Organizer with Insulated Cup Holder Detachable Phone Bag & Shoulder Strap, Fits for Stroller like Uppababy, Baby Jogger, Britax, BOB, Umbrella and Pet Stroller
Purchased
Boppy New Nursing Pillow – Tan Checkered Stripes – Larger, Firmer, More Supportive Pillow for Breastfeeding & Bottle Feeding
Purchased
Gerber Baby 10-Pack Terry Washcloths, Bear Green, One Size
Purchased
Munchkin Diaper Change Organizer
Purchased
Graco EveryStep 6 in 1 High Chair, Babies and Toddlers Portable Slim High Chair with 6 Growing Stages from Infant to Toddler Seating, Convenient for Dining Time, Featured Design in Misty
Purchased
Baby Einstein Sea Dreams Soother Musical Crib Toy And Sound Machine
Purchased
Lambs & Ivy Disney Baby Winnie The Pooh Hugs White Fitted Crib Sheet
Purchased
Ubbi Retractable On the Go Bag Dispenser for Travel, Diaper Bag Accessory Must Have for Newborn, Helpful Item, Baby Gift, Lavender Scented, Gray
Purchased
Burt's Bees Baby Dusting Powder, Talc Free and Hypoallergenic for Safe and Gentle Comfort, 100% Natural Origin, Pediatrician Tested, 7.5 Oz
Purchased
Little Tikes 2-in-1 Snug n Secure Toddler/Bucket Swing - Pink
Purchased
Munchkin® Super Scoop™ Hanging Bath Toy Storage with Quick Drying Mesh, Grey
Purchased
Sassy Whirling Waterfall Suction Toy
Purchased
Hape Hedgehog Teether
Purchased
Safety 1st Plug Protectors - 36pack
Purchased
Munchkin Laundry Hamper
Purchased
Disney Forever Pooh Lamp with Shade & Bulb
Purchased
Lambs & Ivy Pillow - Storytime Pooh
Purchased
Pearhead Chevron Memory Baby Book - Grey
Purchased
Pearhead Baby Briefcase and Document Organizer, All In One Expanding File Folder, Baby's Paperwork and Records, Newborn Keepsake and Memory Box with Labels, Baby Girl or Baby Boy Gift, Gray Chevron
Purchased
Dr. Brown's Original Nipple, Level 3 (6m+), 6 Count
Purchased
Doona Latch Base - Compatible with Doona Car Seat & Stroller
Purchased
Munchkin Pacifier Portable Electric Uv-sterilizer
Purchased
Bottle Washer Pro®: Automatic Baby Bottle Washer | Baby Brezza
Purchased
Skip Hop Moby All-In-One Elbow Saver & Kneeler - Grey
Purchased
Dr. Brown's Pacifier and Bottle Wipes, 40 Count
Purchased
Girls' Long Sleeve Puppy Bodysuit (Baby)
