skip to main content
Babylist Registry Photo

Caitlin + Nick’s Baby Registry

Caitlin & Nick Mathwig
Poynette, WI
December 29, 2026
We are so excited to welcome baby boy Mathwig this December! We appreciate all your love and support🩵

Sleeping

BaybyNest Crib Mattress 52x27.5x6 with Lyocell Cover - Dual-Sided Comfort, Breathable Gel Memory Foam Inner & Washable Cover, Fits Standard CribsMost wanted
BaybyNest Crib Mattress 52x27.5x6 with Lyocell Cover - Dual-Sided Comfort, Breathable Gel Memory Foam Inner & Washable Cover, Fits Standard Cribs
target Icon
$134.99
Small Story Organic Cotton Jersey Crib Sheet - Little Bear
Small Story Organic Cotton Jersey Crib Sheet - Little Bear
babylist Icon
$18.99
2pk Organic Baby Bassinet Sheets Boys, Girls, Fitted Sheet (Pine Grove)
2pk Organic Baby Bassinet Sheets Boys, Girls, Fitted Sheet (Pine Grove)
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$15.26
Bellini Organic Jersey Cotton Crib Sheet and Changing Pad Cover Set - Tan Stripe
Bellini Organic Jersey Cotton Crib Sheet and Changing Pad Cover Set - Tan Stripe
babylist Icon
$49.99

Baby gear

Frida Baby Hands Free Rocker
Frida Baby Hands Free Rocker
babylist Icon
$59.99
target Icon

Feeding

8pk Lumi Muslin Baby Bibs, Bandana Bibs for Baby Boy, Baby Girl, Muslin Drool Bib for Newborn, Toddler Girl, Boy (Mirage)
8pk Lumi Muslin Baby Bibs, Bandana Bibs for Baby Boy, Baby Girl, Muslin Drool Bib for Newborn, Toddler Girl, Boy (Mirage)
amazon Icon
target Icon
nordstrom Icon
from
$16.96
Sprucely Weighted Straw Sippy Cup (2 Pack) - Green/Sand, 8 Oz
Sprucely Weighted Straw Sippy Cup (2 Pack) - Green/Sand, 8 Oz
babylist Icon
$12.99
AEIOU Infant Feeding Spoon (4 Pack) - Multi Color
AEIOU Infant Feeding Spoon (4 Pack) - Multi Color
babylist Icon
$23.99
Burt's Bees Baby Organic Burp Cloth (5 Pack) - Cow
Burt's Bees Baby Organic Burp Cloth (5 Pack) - Cow
babylist Icon
$32.99
AEIOU Bib (2 Pack) - Sage/Oat Milk
AEIOU Bib (2 Pack) - Sage/Oat Milk
babylist Icon
$19.00
Parker Baby Co. Muslin Cotton Burp Cloths (4-Pack) - Estes Set
Parker Baby Co. Muslin Cotton Burp Cloths (4-Pack) - Estes Set
target Icon
walmart Icon
nordstrom Icon
from
$19.95

Health & safety

Itzy Ritzy Silicone Teether with Sensory Popper - Mushroom
Itzy Ritzy Silicone Teether with Sensory Popper - Mushroom
babylist Icon
$11.99
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
Comfy Cubs Pacifier Clips 100% Food Grade Silicone (2 Pack) - Beige, Light Beige, And White
Comfy Cubs Pacifier Clips 100% Food Grade Silicone (2 Pack) - Beige, Light Beige, And White
babylist Icon
$13.22 Was $19.99
target Icon
Copper Pearl Binky Clip Set (3 Pack) - Chip
Copper Pearl Binky Clip Set (3 Pack) - Chip
babylist Icon
$17.99 Was $18.00
Philips Avent Soothie - 0-3m - Green - 2pk: BPA-Free Silicone Infant Pacifiers for Calming Comfort
Philips Avent Soothie - 0-3m - Green - 2pk: BPA-Free Silicone Infant Pacifiers for Calming Comfort
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
from
$4.47

Bathing

Small Story Organic Cotton Washcloth (6 Pack) - Gray Bees, 6
Small Story Organic Cotton Washcloth (6 Pack) - Gray Bees, 6
babylist Icon
$10.49 Was $14.99
30% off
Munchkin Super Scoop Hanging Bath Toy Organizer, Grey
Munchkin Super Scoop Hanging Bath Toy Organizer, Grey
target Icon
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
from
$11.59
Milou Sea Creature Bath Toys - Multi
Milou Sea Creature Bath Toys - Multi
babylist Icon
$22.99

Clothing

Baby Boys' 3pk Ribbed Hats - Cloud Island™ Blue/tan/white 0-6M
Baby Boys' 3pk Ribbed Hats - Cloud Island™ Blue/tan/white 0-6M
target Icon
$7.00
Bear Ears Newborn Baby Hat and Mitten Set Infant Beanie 0-3 Months
Bear Ears Newborn Baby Hat and Mitten Set Infant Beanie 0-3 Months
amazon Icon
$9.99
Yoofoss Baby Sleepers 5 Pack 100% Organic Cotton, Girl Boys Newborn Pajamas
Yoofoss Baby Sleepers 5 Pack 100% Organic Cotton, Girl Boys Newborn Pajamas
amazon Icon
$37.99
Simple Joys by Carter's Unisex Baby 2-pack Neutral Fleece Footed Sleep and Play
Simple Joys by Carter's Unisex Baby 2-pack Neutral Fleece Footed Sleep and Play
amazon Icon
$19.16
Carter's Just One You® Baby Boys' Polar Bear Sleep N' Play - Sage Green 3M
Carter's Just One You® Baby Boys' Polar Bear Sleep N' Play - Sage Green 3M
target Icon
$7.00
Carter's Just One You® Baby Boys' Mammoth Sleep N' Play - Brown/Ivory 3M
Carter's Just One You® Baby Boys' Mammoth Sleep N' Play - Brown/Ivory 3M
target Icon
$9.00
Gerber Baby Boys' 4 Pack Sleep 'N Play Footie
Gerber Baby Boys' 4 Pack Sleep 'N Play Footie
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$25.95
Small Story Short Sleeve Solid Organic Cotton Bodysuits (5 Pack) - Core Neutrals, 3-6 M
Small Story Short Sleeve Solid Organic Cotton Bodysuits (5 Pack) - Core Neutrals, 3-6 M
babylist Icon
$17.49 Was $24.99
30% off
Carter's Cotton Pants (2 Pack) - Blue, 3M
Carter's Cotton Pants (2 Pack) - Blue, 3M
babylist Icon
$24.00
Goumi Kids Stay-On Baby Booties (2 pack) - Boulder + Birch, 0-3 M
Goumi Kids Stay-On Baby Booties (2 pack) - Boulder + Birch, 0-3 M
babylist Icon
$36.00
Gerber Baby 2pk Jogger Pants - Tan 3-6M
Gerber Baby 2pk Jogger Pants - Tan 3-6M
target Icon
$10.99
Small Story Organic Cotton Solid Pants (5 Pack) - Core Neutrals, 0-3 M
Small Story Organic Cotton Solid Pants (5 Pack) - Core Neutrals, 0-3 M
babylist Icon
$24.49 Was $34.99
30% off
Gerber Baby 4pk Long Sleeve Onesies - Neutral 3-6M: Cotton Knit Bodysuits, Pullover Crotch Snap
Gerber Baby 4pk Long Sleeve Onesies - Neutral 3-6M: Cotton Knit Bodysuits, Pullover Crotch Snap
target Icon
$11.20
The Peanutshell Baby Boys and Girls 12pk Organic Cotton Socks, Soothing Neutrals, 3-12 Months
The Peanutshell Baby Boys and Girls 12pk Organic Cotton Socks, Soothing Neutrals, 3-12 Months
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$19.99
Gerber Baby 3pk Long Sleeve Onesies Bodysuit - White 3-6M: Cotton Crew Neck, Adjustable Snap Closure
Gerber Baby 3pk Long Sleeve Onesies Bodysuit - White 3-6M: Cotton Crew Neck, Adjustable Snap Closure
target Icon
$7.00
Small Story Organic Cotton 3-Piece Gift Set - Beary Good, 0-3 M
Small Story Organic Cotton 3-Piece Gift Set - Beary Good, 0-3 M
babylist Icon
$18.19 Was $25.99
30% off
Hudson Baby Basics Infant Boy Comfy Cotton Pants 4-Pack, Forest Plaid, 0-3 Months
Hudson Baby Basics Infant Boy Comfy Cotton Pants 4-Pack, Forest Plaid, 0-3 Months
target Icon
$13.08
Gerber Baby 3pk Long Sleeve Onesies Bodysuit - White 0-3M: Cotton Knit, Adjustable Snap Closure
Gerber Baby 3pk Long Sleeve Onesies Bodysuit - White 0-3M: Cotton Knit, Adjustable Snap Closure
target Icon
$7.00

Playing

Lovevery Drop & Find Ball Box
Lovevery Drop & Find Ball Box
babylist Icon
$28.96
walmart Icon
Pearhead Wooden Stacking Toy Tower
Pearhead Wooden Stacking Toy Tower
babylist Icon
$25.99
target Icon
amazon Icon
Baby Einstein Glow & Discover Light Bar Musical Toy, Activity Station, Sitting Up and Tummy Time Toy, Color and Animal Learning Toy, Infant Ages 3 Months+
Baby Einstein Glow & Discover Light Bar Musical Toy, Activity Station, Sitting Up and Tummy Time Toy, Color and Animal Learning Toy, Infant Ages 3 Months+
babylist Icon
$35.99
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
target Icon
Black and White High Contrast Toys for Baby 0-3 3-6 months Infant Tummy Time Soft Crinkle Book Mirror Sensory Toys 0 2 4 5 6 Month Old Babies Boy Gril Newborn Development Christmas Stocking Stuffer
Black and White High Contrast Toys for Baby 0-3 3-6 months Infant Tummy Time Soft Crinkle Book Mirror Sensory Toys 0 2 4 5 6 Month Old Babies Boy Gril Newborn Development Christmas Stocking Stuffer
amazon Icon
$11.99
Skip Hop Bandana Buddies Stroller Toy - Puppy
Skip Hop Bandana Buddies Stroller Toy - Puppy
babylist Icon
$17.27
target Icon
amazon Icon
Lamaze Freddie The Firefly Clip & Go Stroller Toy
Lamaze Freddie The Firefly Clip & Go Stroller Toy
babylist Icon
$25.99
target Icon
amazon Icon
Itzy Ritzy Car Seat Activity Toy - Rainbow
Itzy Ritzy Car Seat Activity Toy - Rainbow
babylist Icon
$32.99
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
Sassy Rookie Books Baby Box Set
Sassy Rookie Books Baby Box Set
babylist Icon
$37.99
target Icon
amazon Icon
Manhattan Toy Toy Winkel Rattle
Manhattan Toy Toy Winkel Rattle
babylist Icon
$16.19 Was $18.00
amazon Icon
Janod Alphabet Puzzle
Janod Alphabet Puzzle
babylist Icon
$35.99
crateandbarrel Icon
amazon Icon
Sassy Stacks of Circles Stem Toy
Sassy Stacks of Circles Stem Toy
babylist Icon
$16.69
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
Melissa & Doug Take-Along Farm Play Mat
Melissa & Doug Take-Along Farm Play Mat
babylist Icon
$26.99 Was $35.99
25% off
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
Melissa & Doug Flip Fish Baby Toy
Melissa & Doug Flip Fish Baby Toy
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
+1
from
$15.97
Infantino Pat & Play Water Mat Wee Wild Ones - Narwhal
Infantino Pat & Play Water Mat Wee Wild Ones - Narwhal
babylist Icon
$24.99
walmart Icon
target Icon

General

Munchkin Brica 360° Pivot Baby In-Sight Adjustable Car Mirror - Black: Plastic Safety Back Seat Accessory
Munchkin Brica 360° Pivot Baby In-Sight Adjustable Car Mirror - Black: Plastic Safety Back Seat Accessory
target Icon
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
from
$18.99

Cash & gift cards

Babylist Shop Gift Card
Babylist Shop Gift Card
From $25 to $1,000

Purchased

Babysense HD Split Screen Video Baby Monitor HD S2 - 1 Camera
Purchased
Babysense HD Split Screen Video Baby Monitor HD S2 - 1 Camera
Chicco Activ3 and KeyFit 30 Jogging Travel System - Solar
Purchased
Chicco Activ3 and KeyFit 30 Jogging Travel System - Solar
Ingenuity Nestle Vibrating Rocker, Lightweight Foldable Infant Seat with Breathable Fabric, 2-Position Recline, Mini Vibration Unit, 5-Point Harness
Purchased
Ingenuity Nestle Vibrating Rocker, Lightweight Foldable Infant Seat with Breathable Fabric, 2-Position Recline, Mini Vibration Unit, 5-Point Harness
Comfy Cubs Baby Pacifier - 100% Food Grade Silicone Breast-like Nipple Shape - 0+ Months, 5 Pack - Multicolor Boy
Purchased
Comfy Cubs Baby Pacifier - 100% Food Grade Silicone Breast-like Nipple Shape - 0+ Months, 5 Pack - Multicolor Boy
Ingenuity Step & Sprout 3-in-1 Baby Activity Walker - First Forest
Purchased
Ingenuity Step & Sprout 3-in-1 Baby Activity Walker - First Forest
Graco Pack n' Play Close2Baby Seat Lux Playard - Soft Almond
Purchased
Graco Pack n' Play Close2Baby Seat Lux Playard - Soft Almond
Quilted Diaper Backpack Tote - Black - Cloud Island™
Purchased
Quilted Diaper Backpack Tote - Black - Cloud Island™
Carter's Just One You® Baby Boys' Crew Socks 8pk - Brown/Blue/White 0-3M
Purchased
Carter's Just One You® Baby Boys' Crew Socks 8pk - Brown/Blue/White 0-3M
Baby Brezza Bottle Washer Pro - White
Purchased
Baby Brezza Bottle Washer Pro - White
Delta Children Bondi Beechwood By The Bed Bassinet
Purchased
Delta Children Bondi Beechwood By The Bed Bassinet
Itzy Ritzy Bitzy Shake Teether - White
Purchased
Itzy Ritzy Bitzy Shake Teether - White
Blissful Diary Baby Play Gym Mat, Play Mat Activity Mat with 6 Detachable Toys for Stage-Based Sensory & Motor Skill Development, Easy to Install & Clean, Baby Essentials Gift, Brown Checkerboard
Purchased
Blissful Diary Baby Play Gym Mat, Play Mat Activity Mat with 6 Detachable Toys for Stage-Based Sensory & Motor Skill Development, Easy to Install & Clean, Baby Essentials Gift, Brown Checkerboard
Comfy Cubs Cotton Muslin Hooded Baby Towel (2 Pack) - Pacific Blue And Fern
Purchased
Comfy Cubs Cotton Muslin Hooded Baby Towel (2 Pack) - Pacific Blue And Fern
Momcozy 9-in-1 Nutri Bottle Warmer
Purchased
Momcozy 9-in-1 Nutri Bottle Warmer
Baby Crib Mobile for Boys Girls Dog theme Baby Mobile for Crib Mobile for Bassinet with Felt Ball, White-blue
Purchased
Baby Crib Mobile for Boys Girls Dog theme Baby Mobile for Crib Mobile for Bassinet with Felt Ball, White-blue
Macmillan Your Baby's First Word Will Be DADA
Purchased
Macmillan Your Baby's First Word Will Be DADA
Crib Mobile Holder, HBM Wooden Mobile Arm & Hanger for Crib, Nursery Decor for Baby Girl Boy
Purchased
Crib Mobile Holder, HBM Wooden Mobile Arm & Hanger for Crib, Nursery Decor for Baby Girl Boy
Small Story High-Pile Fleece Bunting - Hazelnut, 3-6 M
Purchased
Small Story High-Pile Fleece Bunting - Hazelnut, 3-6 M
Dreambaby Silicone Pop-Up Snack Cup, 2-Piece Set
Purchased
Dreambaby Silicone Pop-Up Snack Cup, 2-Piece Set
Parker Baby Co. Felt Diaper Caddy Organizer - Regular, Oatmeal
Purchased
Parker Baby Co. Felt Diaper Caddy Organizer - Regular, Oatmeal
Baby Boys' 4pk Short Sleeve Bodysuits - Cloud Island™ Blue/green/tan 6-9M
Purchased
Baby Boys' 4pk Short Sleeve Bodysuits - Cloud Island™ Blue/green/tan 6-9M
Baby Boys' 3pk Ribbed Cotton Jogger Pants - Cloud Island™ Blue/Green/ Tan 3-6M
Purchased
Baby Boys' 3pk Ribbed Cotton Jogger Pants - Cloud Island™ Blue/Green/ Tan 3-6M
Kinder King 7 in 1 Baby High Chair Convert to Wooden Feeding Chair Removable Tray 5-Point Harness Gray
Purchased
Kinder King 7 in 1 Baby High Chair Convert to Wooden Feeding Chair Removable Tray 5-Point Harness Gray
Hatch Hatch Go Sound Machine - Greige
Purchased
Hatch Hatch Go Sound Machine - Greige
Hatch Hatch Baby Sound Machine - Greige
Purchased
Hatch Hatch Baby Sound Machine - Greige
Carter's Just One You® Baby Boys' 2pk bears Long Sleeve Sleep N Plays - Brown/white 3M
Purchased
Carter's Just One You® Baby Boys' 2pk bears Long Sleeve Sleep N Plays - Brown/white 3M
Inglesina Fast Table Chair - Cream
Purchased
Inglesina Fast Table Chair - Cream
Infantino Busy Board Mirror & Sensory Discovery Toy
Purchased
Infantino Busy Board Mirror & Sensory Discovery Toy
Earth Mama Organic Diaper Balm - 2 Oz, 2
Purchased
Earth Mama Organic Diaper Balm - 2 Oz, 2
Tiny Twinkle Portable/Foldable Waterproof Diaper Changing Pad with Smart Wipes Pocket (Beige Checkers)
Purchased
Tiny Twinkle Portable/Foldable Waterproof Diaper Changing Pad with Smart Wipes Pocket (Beige Checkers)
Tiny Twinkle Waterproof Changing Pad for Dresser – Wipeable, Non-Slip Base, Safety Strap & Washable Cover (Beige Checkers)
Purchased
Tiny Twinkle Waterproof Changing Pad for Dresser – Wipeable, Non-Slip Base, Safety Strap & Washable Cover (Beige Checkers)
lulumoon Muslin Changing Pad Cover: 32x16 Fit Standard Rectangle Pad
Purchased
lulumoon Muslin Changing Pad Cover: 32x16 Fit Standard Rectangle Pad
Momcozy All-in-1 Core Baby Kit
Purchased
Momcozy All-in-1 Core Baby Kit
Philips Avent Glass Natural Bottle with Natural Response Nipple, Baby Set
Purchased
Philips Avent Glass Natural Bottle with Natural Response Nipple, Baby Set
Little Unicorn Cotton Muslin Swaddle 3 Pack - Woodland Friends
Purchased
Little Unicorn Cotton Muslin Swaddle 3 Pack - Woodland Friends
Ingenuity SwaddleMe Monogram Collection Swaddle (3-Pack) - Safari, 0-3 M
Purchased
Ingenuity SwaddleMe Monogram Collection Swaddle (3-Pack) - Safari, 0-3 M
Tiny Kind Organic Cotton Wearable Swaddle 1.0 TOG - Ashley Blue, 0-6 M
Purchased
Tiny Kind Organic Cotton Wearable Swaddle 1.0 TOG - Ashley Blue, 0-6 M
Carter's Hooded Terry Robe - Blue Bear, 0-9 M
Purchased
Carter's Hooded Terry Robe - Blue Bear, 0-9 M
Angelcare Soft-Touch Baby Bath Support & Rinser Bundle, Aqua
Purchased
Angelcare Soft-Touch Baby Bath Support & Rinser Bundle, Aqua
Pearhead Shape Sorter Carrying Bucket
Purchased
Pearhead Shape Sorter Carrying Bucket
Monthly Baby Milestone and First Holiday Signs, Wooden Baby Months Disc Set 1-12, Hello World Newborn Announcement Props (Blue)
Purchased
Monthly Baby Milestone and First Holiday Signs, Wooden Baby Months Disc Set 1-12, Hello World Newborn Announcement Props (Blue)
XUANGUO Cotton Rope Laundry Basket Hamper for Clothes Large Brown and White
Purchased
XUANGUO Cotton Rope Laundry Basket Hamper for Clothes Large Brown and White
Melissa & Doug PB&J Take-Along Toy
Purchased
Melissa & Doug PB&J Take-Along Toy
Skip Hop Stroll & Go Car Seat Cover - Black
Purchased
Skip Hop Stroll & Go Car Seat Cover - Black
Love to Dream Swaddle Up Transition Bag Original 1.0 TOG - Gray, Medium
Purchased
Love to Dream Swaddle Up Transition Bag Original 1.0 TOG - Gray, Medium
Itzy Ritzy Mom Boss Multi Use Cover - Tan Check
Purchased
Itzy Ritzy Mom Boss Multi Use Cover - Tan Check
Magnetic Me Fleece Mittens - Cream, 0-6 M
Purchased
Magnetic Me Fleece Mittens - Cream, 0-6 M
Magnetic Me Fleece Hat - Cream, 0-6 M
Purchased
Magnetic Me Fleece Hat - Cream, 0-6 M
Simple Joys by Carter's Unisex Baby 2-pack Neutral Fleece Footed Sleep and Play
Purchased
Simple Joys by Carter's Unisex Baby 2-pack Neutral Fleece Footed Sleep and Play
Macmillan 100 First Words
Purchased
Macmillan 100 First Words
LifeTree Crib Sheets for Baby Unisex - Muslin Fitted Crib Sheets Toddler Bed Sheet, 70% Viscose from Bamboo and 30% Cotton, Fits Standard Crib, Golden Retriever, 28in x 52in
Purchased
LifeTree Crib Sheets for Baby Unisex - Muslin Fitted Crib Sheets Toddler Bed Sheet, 70% Viscose from Bamboo and 30% Cotton, Fits Standard Crib, Golden Retriever, 28in x 52in
Geometric Interactive Playmat - Cloud Island™: Shapes Pattern, 40" x 40"
Purchased
Geometric Interactive Playmat - Cloud Island™: Shapes Pattern, 40" x 40"
david's kids 4 Pack Baby Muslin Swaddle Blankets, 100% Cotton and Ultra Soft Breathable Receiving Blanket Wrap for Boys Girls, New Born Essentials, Large 47 x 47 inches, Woodland Animals/Green
Purchased
david's kids 4 Pack Baby Muslin Swaddle Blankets, 100% Cotton and Ultra Soft Breathable Receiving Blanket Wrap for Boys Girls, New Born Essentials, Large 47 x 47 inches, Woodland Animals/Green
Boppy Boppy x Babylist Nursing Pillow with Organic Cotton Cover - Camel Stitch Stripe
Purchased
Boppy Boppy x Babylist Nursing Pillow with Organic Cotton Cover - Camel Stitch Stripe