skip to main content
C+C

Carly & Christian's Baby Registry

Carly Smetana & Christian Tolbert
Chicago, IL
February 12, 2026

We are so excited for the chance to see and spend time with everyone who can join us in honoring this next chapter of our lives. Your presence means the world to us, and while gifts are by no means necessary, they are always appreciated.

If you’d like to give something, we kindly ask that you consider choosing from our baby registry so we can be sure to have the essentials we’ll truly use. Outside of the registry, we love sentimental or handmade gifts, or items you found to be must-haves when caring for your own little ones.

We’d also be delighted if you brought your favorite baby or children’s book to help us start building a cozy library. We are trying to keep material items to a thoughtful minimum, so if you prefer, a contribution to one of our various funds would be a wonderful and practical way to help.

Most of all, we’re simply looking forward to celebrating with you with a cozy afternoon of quality time, games (cards, zilch, spinner, and more!), and good eats!

**Thanks to generous donations from family and friends we do not need any additional newborn or 0-3 month clothing items**

Feeding

mushie Fresh Food Feeder Freezer Tray with Lid for Frozen Baby Food | 9 Cups x 0.34 oz | BPA Free Storage Container (Tradewinds)
mushie Fresh Food Feeder Freezer Tray with Lid for Frozen Baby Food | 9 Cups x 0.34 oz | BPA Free Storage Container (Tradewinds)
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$11.99
mushie Toddler Ice Pop Tray (Blush) | 4 Pieces x 1 oz | BPA Free
mushie Toddler Ice Pop Tray (Blush) | 4 Pieces x 1 oz | BPA Free
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$15.99
mushie 100% Silicone Baby Sippy Cup | 6 Months+ (Natural)
mushie 100% Silicone Baby Sippy Cup | 6 Months+ (Natural)
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$16.99
mushie Silicone Baby Starter Training Cup | 6 Months+ (Cambridge Blue)
mushie Silicone Baby Starter Training Cup | 6 Months+ (Cambridge Blue)
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$11.99
mushie Silicone Toddler Starter Spoons | 2 Pack (Tradewinds/Shifting Sand)
mushie Silicone Toddler Starter Spoons | 2 Pack (Tradewinds/Shifting Sand)
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$14.99
mushie Silicone First Feeding Baby Spoons | 2 Pack (Cambridge Blue/Shifting Sand)
mushie Silicone First Feeding Baby Spoons | 2 Pack (Cambridge Blue/Shifting Sand)
amazon Icon
$14.99
mushie Silicone Baby Feeding Spoons | 2 Pack (Dried Thyme/Natural)
mushie Silicone Baby Feeding Spoons | 2 Pack (Dried Thyme/Natural)
amazon Icon
$12.99
mushie Silicone Suction Bowl | BPA-Free Non-Slip Design (Cloudy Mauve)
mushie Silicone Suction Bowl | BPA-Free Non-Slip Design (Cloudy Mauve)
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$14.99
mushie Silicone Suction Plate | BPA-Free Non-Slip Design (Dried Thyme)
mushie Silicone Suction Plate | BPA-Free Non-Slip Design (Dried Thyme)
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$16.99

Sleeping

Love to Dream Swaddle Up Original 1.0 TOG - Gray, Small
Love to Dream Swaddle Up Original 1.0 TOG - Gray, Small
babylist Icon
$34.95
target Icon
amazon Icon
Bassinet Cover to Keep Cats Out, Mosquito Net Cover with 2-Way Zipper for Baby Crib, White
Bassinet Cover to Keep Cats Out, Mosquito Net Cover with 2-Way Zipper for Baby Crib, White
amazon Icon
$17.99
Deluxe Travel Crib & Play Yard - Grey
Deluxe Travel Crib & Play Yard - Grey
babylist Icon
$299.99
amazon Icon
Check Mates Sleepy Bag - Little Sleepies
Check Mates Sleepy Bag - Little Sleepies
littlesleepies Icon
$50.00
Desert Sunrise Sleepy Bag - Little Sleepies
Desert Sunrise Sleepy Bag - Little Sleepies
littlesleepies Icon
$55.00
Breathe Safe™ Breathable Mattress Cover (Halo Bassinet)
Wants: 2
Breathe Safe™ Breathable Mattress Cover (Halo Bassinet)
lullabyearth Icon
$39.00
Fitted Sheets for Baby Trend® Nursery Center® Playards
Wants: 2
Fitted Sheets for Baby Trend® Nursery Center® Playards
babytrend Icon
$19.99
Travel Crib & Play Yard Sheets - Travel Crib & Play Yard
Travel Crib & Play Yard Sheets - Travel Crib & Play Yard
newtonbaby Icon
amazon Icon
from
$39.99

Diapering

California Baby Super Sensitive Diaper Rash Cream | 100% Bio-Based | Zinc Oxide Ointment | Unscented Diaper Cream | Cloth Diapers Safe | 82 g / 2.9 oz
California Baby Super Sensitive Diaper Rash Cream | 100% Bio-Based | Zinc Oxide Ointment | Unscented Diaper Cream | Cloth Diapers Safe | 82 g / 2.9 oz
amazon Icon
$18.90
Pampers Sensitive Baby Wipes - 1008ct
Pampers Sensitive Baby Wipes - 1008ct
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
from
$33.99

Baby Gear

Green Bay Packers Toy Collection - Pacifier Clip - Rattle - Go Pack Go - Baby Packers Toy Rattle - Green - Yellow - Football - Baby Gift
Green Bay Packers Toy Collection - Pacifier Clip - Rattle - Go Pack Go - Baby Packers Toy Rattle - Green - Yellow - Football - Baby Gift
etsy Icon
$54.99
In the Jungle - Cotton Free-to-Grow Baby Carrier – Baby Tula US
In the Jungle - Cotton Free-to-Grow Baby Carrier – Baby Tula US
babytula Icon
$179.00
Amazon.com: mushie : Teethers
Wants: 5
Amazon.com: mushie : Teethers
amazon Icon
$12.99
ThePacii™ 3 Pack
ThePacii™ 3 Pack
thepacii Icon
$28.95
Ergobaby Evolve 3-in-1 Baby Bouncer Seat, Adjustable Multi-Position Infant Bouncer and Toddler Chair, Soft Knit and Breathable Mesh Fabric, Converts from Newborn to Toddler - Oxford Blue
Ergobaby Evolve 3-in-1 Baby Bouncer Seat, Adjustable Multi-Position Infant Bouncer and Toddler Chair, Soft Knit and Breathable Mesh Fabric, Converts from Newborn to Toddler - Oxford Blue
babylist Icon
$219.00
amazon Icon

Health & Safety

LifeVac Home Kit 2 Pack - Portable Suction Rescue Device, First Aid Kit for Kids and Adults, Portable Airway Suction Device for Children and Adults
LifeVac Home Kit 2 Pack - Portable Suction Rescue Device, First Aid Kit for Kids and Adults, Portable Airway Suction Device for Children and Adults
amazon Icon
$139.99

Bathing

Canopy Bath Tub Filter | Water Filter for Bath Tub - Canopy
Canopy Bath Tub Filter | Water Filter for Bath Tub - Canopy
getcanopy Icon
$89.00
Frida Baby Soft Sink Baby Bath
Frida Baby Soft Sink Baby Bath
babylist Icon
$29.00
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon

Nursery & Decor

Little Dreams by Canopy | Best Humidifier for Babies - Aroma Diffuser
Little Dreams by Canopy | Best Humidifier for Babies - Aroma Diffuser
getcanopy Icon
$159.00

Playing

Hape Wonder Walker Push and Pull Toy - Award Winning
Hape Wonder Walker Push and Pull Toy - Award Winning
hapetoys Icon
$170.00
The Charmer Play Kit | 3- to 4-Month-Old Baby Toys | Lovevery
The Charmer Play Kit | 3- to 4-Month-Old Baby Toys | Lovevery
lovevery Icon
$92.00
The Senser Play Kit | 5- to 6-Month-Old Baby Toys | Lovevery
The Senser Play Kit | 5- to 6-Month-Old Baby Toys | Lovevery
lovevery Icon
$92.00
The Inspector Play Kit | 7- to 8-Month-Old Baby Toys | Lovevery
The Inspector Play Kit | 7- to 8-Month-Old Baby Toys | Lovevery
lovevery Icon
$92.00
The Explorer Play Kit | 9- to 10-Month-Old Baby Toys | Lovevery
The Explorer Play Kit | 9- to 10-Month-Old Baby Toys | Lovevery
lovevery Icon
$96.00
The Thinker Play Kit | Toys for 11- Month and 1-Year-Olds | Lovevery
The Thinker Play Kit | Toys for 11- Month and 1-Year-Olds | Lovevery
lovevery Icon
$92.00
The Looker Play Kit | Toys for Newborn to 12 Week Olds | Lovevery
The Looker Play Kit | Toys for Newborn to 12 Week Olds | Lovevery
lovevery Icon
$92.00

General

Shark Ninja NeverChange Air Purifier Compact Pro
Shark Ninja NeverChange Air Purifier Compact Pro
sharkninja Icon
$129.99

Cash & Gift Cards

Diaper Fund
Diaper Fund
Any amount
Venmo
Parental Leave Fund
Parental Leave Fund
Any amount
Venmo
College Fund
College Fund
Any amount
Venmo
Meal Fund
Meal Fund
Any amount
Venmo
Babylist Shop Gift Card
Babylist Shop Gift Card
From $25 to $1,000

Purchased

Skip Hop Diaper Bag Backpack: Forma, Multi-Function Baby Travel Bag with Changing Pad & Stroller Attachment, Jet Black
Purchased
Skip Hop Diaper Bag Backpack: Forma, Multi-Function Baby Travel Bag with Changing Pad & Stroller Attachment, Jet Black
Frida Baby 3-in-1 Rectal, Underarm & Oral Thermometer for Kids, Digital Baby Thermometer for Infants, Toddlers, & Kids
Purchased
Frida Baby 3-in-1 Rectal, Underarm & Oral Thermometer for Kids, Digital Baby Thermometer for Infants, Toddlers, & Kids
Baby Basics Kit
Purchased
Baby Basics Kit
Boba Baby Wrap Carrier – Original Baby Sling Carrier for Newborns (7–35 lbs), Soft, Secure, Hands-Free & Ergonomic, Ideal for Comfortable Bonding, New Parents (Grey)
Purchased
Boba Baby Wrap Carrier – Original Baby Sling Carrier for Newborns (7–35 lbs), Soft, Secure, Hands-Free & Ergonomic, Ideal for Comfortable Bonding, New Parents (Grey)
My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow - Deluxe - Enhanced Comfort w/ Slipcover - Ergonomic Breastfeeding Pillow For Ultimate Support For Mom & Baby - Adjustable Pillow W/ Handy Side Pocket, Soft Rose
Purchased
My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow - Deluxe - Enhanced Comfort w/ Slipcover - Ergonomic Breastfeeding Pillow For Ultimate Support For Mom & Baby - Adjustable Pillow W/ Handy Side Pocket, Soft Rose
Doona + Car Seat & Stroller
Purchased
Doona + Car Seat & Stroller
Muslin Burp Cloths in Multicolor
Purchased
Muslin Burp Cloths in Multicolor
DreamMore™ Bedside Bassinet Deluxe with Calming Motion
Purchased
DreamMore™ Bedside Bassinet Deluxe with Calming Motion
Janice Power Swivel Nursery Glider Recliner with Power Headrest
Purchased
Janice Power Swivel Nursery Glider Recliner with Power Headrest
Jeep Milestone 6-in-1 High Chair by Delta Children - High Chair Converts to Stool, Booster Seat, Toddler Chair, Activity Table and Desk and Chair, Sage Green
Purchased
Jeep Milestone 6-in-1 High Chair by Delta Children - High Chair Converts to Stool, Booster Seat, Toddler Chair, Activity Table and Desk and Chair, Sage Green
Comfy Cubs Muslin Swaddle Blankets Pack of 4, 47 x 47 Inches, Soft Cotton - Wine, Neptune, Fern, Caramel
Purchased
Comfy Cubs Muslin Swaddle Blankets Pack of 4, 47 x 47 Inches, Soft Cotton - Wine, Neptune, Fern, Caramel
Philips Avent 3pk Glass Natural Baby Bottle with Natural Response Nipple - Clear - 8oz
Purchased
Philips Avent 3pk Glass Natural Baby Bottle with Natural Response Nipple - Clear - 8oz
Willow - Portable Breastmilk Cooler - Keeps Breast Milk Cold for 24 Hours - Stainless Steel - Insulated - Reuseable - Breastfeeding Essentials - Storage Container w/Gel Ice Pack - Purple - 16oz
Purchased
Willow - Portable Breastmilk Cooler - Keeps Breast Milk Cold for 24 Hours - Stainless Steel - Insulated - Reuseable - Breastfeeding Essentials - Storage Container w/Gel Ice Pack - Purple - 16oz
Willow - Glass Breastmilk Pitcher - Dishwasher Safe - 32oz Capacity - Wide Mouth Jar for Easy Transfer & Cleaning - Easy Pour Spout into Bottles or Breast Milk Storage Bags - Breastfeeding Essentials
Purchased
Willow - Glass Breastmilk Pitcher - Dishwasher Safe - 32oz Capacity - Wide Mouth Jar for Easy Transfer & Cleaning - Easy Pour Spout into Bottles or Breast Milk Storage Bags - Breastfeeding Essentials
Dr. Brown's Soft Touch No Scratch Baby Bottle Cleaning Brush Nipple Cleaner with Stand and Storage Clip, BPA Free, Blue 1-Pack
Purchased
Dr. Brown's Soft Touch No Scratch Baby Bottle Cleaning Brush Nipple Cleaner with Stand and Storage Clip, BPA Free, Blue 1-Pack
Dr. Brown's Drying Tower, Stand-Up Drying Rack, Countertop Baby Bottle Drying with Organized Storage for Baby Essentials, Space Saving Vertical Rack
Purchased
Dr. Brown's Drying Tower, Stand-Up Drying Rack, Countertop Baby Bottle Drying with Organized Storage for Baby Essentials, Space Saving Vertical Rack
Owlet Dream Duo 3 Smart Baby Monitor - Mint
Purchased
Owlet Dream Duo 3 Smart Baby Monitor - Mint
The Play Gym
Purchased
The Play Gym
Green Bay Packers Infant Snug as a Bug Sleep Sack at the Packers Pro Shop
Purchased
Green Bay Packers Infant Snug as a Bug Sleep Sack at the Packers Pro Shop
VAVA Baby Egg Night Light with Touch Control
Purchased
VAVA Baby Egg Night Light with Touch Control
The Best Sellers Bundle
Purchased
The Best Sellers Bundle
Momcozy Bottle Sterilizer and Dryer
Purchased
Momcozy Bottle Sterilizer and Dryer
mushie Silicone Baby Bib | Adjustable Fit Waterproof Bibs (Bees)
Purchased
mushie Silicone Baby Bib | Adjustable Fit Waterproof Bibs (Bees)
mushie 100% Silicone Training Cup & Straw for Toddlers | 6 Months+ (Whales)
Purchased
mushie 100% Silicone Training Cup & Straw for Toddlers | 6 Months+ (Whales)
mushie Silicone Snack Cup | Spill Proof Food Container for Toddler and Baby (Dinosaurs)
Purchased
mushie Silicone Snack Cup | Spill Proof Food Container for Toddler and Baby (Dinosaurs)
Mompush Meteor Stroller | Perfect 2 in 1 Bassinet Stroller for Babies | Mompush
Purchased
Mompush Meteor Stroller | Perfect 2 in 1 Bassinet Stroller for Babies | Mompush
mushie Silicone Baby Bib | Adjustable Fit Waterproof Bibs (Bees)
Purchased
mushie Silicone Baby Bib | Adjustable Fit Waterproof Bibs (Bees)
KeaBabies Portable Diaper Changing Pad - Large Waterproof Baby Changing Mat, Compact Travel Diaper Clutch, Functional Pockets Fit Newborn Essentials, Wipeable & Padded Baby Changer (Pets & Paws)
Purchased
KeaBabies Portable Diaper Changing Pad - Large Waterproof Baby Changing Mat, Compact Travel Diaper Clutch, Functional Pockets Fit Newborn Essentials, Wipeable & Padded Baby Changer (Pets & Paws)
Baby playpen, 79"x71"Baby Playpen with Mat Indoor&Outdoor Playpen for Babies and Toddlers with Breathable Play Pen with Ocean Balls Hanging Pocket Basketball Hoop and Football Goal
Purchased
Baby playpen, 79"x71"Baby Playpen with Mat Indoor&Outdoor Playpen for Babies and Toddlers with Breathable Play Pen with Ocean Balls Hanging Pocket Basketball Hoop and Football Goal
Baby Trend Simply Smart™ Nursery Center® Playard
Purchased
Baby Trend Simply Smart™ Nursery Center® Playard
mushie Silicone Baby Fresh Fruit & Food Feeder Pacifier | 6 Months+ (Sage)
Purchased
mushie Silicone Baby Fresh Fruit & Food Feeder Pacifier | 6 Months+ (Sage)
Comfy Cubs Hooded Baby Towel 2-Pack, Large 32 x 32 Inch - 6 Layer 100% Muslin Cotton for Babies, Toddlers, Kids - Soft & Absorbent Baby Bath Towels - Unisex Design for Bath Time, Cedar and Sand
Purchased
Comfy Cubs Hooded Baby Towel 2-Pack, Large 32 x 32 Inch - 6 Layer 100% Muslin Cotton for Babies, Toddlers, Kids - Soft & Absorbent Baby Bath Towels - Unisex Design for Bath Time, Cedar and Sand
Tubby Todd Tubby Todd x Babylist Baby’s Skincare Essentials Gift Set - Lavender & Rosemary
On hold
Tubby Todd Tubby Todd x Babylist Baby’s Skincare Essentials Gift Set - Lavender & Rosemary
Philips Avent 3pk Glass Natural Baby Bottle with Natural Response Nipple - Clear - 8oz
On hold
Philips Avent 3pk Glass Natural Baby Bottle with Natural Response Nipple - Clear - 8oz