skip to main content
Babylist Registry Photo

Caitlin's Baby Registry

Caitlin McMullen & Poppy Slocum
Brooklyn, NY
November 6, 2025
Thanks so much for visiting our registry! A lot of these items are general suggestions - think of them as a vibe (eg the clothes). ❤️ ❤️ ❤️

Feeding

Evenflo 🍼 Balance + Bottles for Breastfed Babies – Evenflo Feeding
Evenflo 🍼 Balance + Bottles for Breastfed Babies – Evenflo Feeding
evenflofeeding Icon
$29.99
Baby-Led™ Tiny Cup
Baby-Led™ Tiny Cup
ezpzfun Icon
$11.49
GREEN SPROUTS Organic Muslin Bibs (5 Pack) - Blue Set
GREEN SPROUTS Organic Muslin Bibs (5 Pack) - Blue Set
amazon Icon
babylist Icon
from
$24.99

Sleeping

Fitted Jersey Crib Sheet Knit Oatmeal Heather - Cloud Island™ Oatmeal
Fitted Jersey Crib Sheet Knit Oatmeal Heather - Cloud Island™ Oatmeal
target Icon
$9.99
Fitted Crib Sheet
Fitted Crib Sheet
hm Icon
$12.00
FITTED CRIB SHEET
FITTED CRIB SHEET
hm Icon
$17.99
Cotton Baby Bassinet Fitted Sheets | SNOO – Happiest Baby
Cotton Baby Bassinet Fitted Sheets | SNOO – Happiest Baby
happiestbaby Icon
$38.50
Front Opening Sleep Sack 1.5 TOG Grey / 0 - 6 M
Front Opening Sleep Sack 1.5 TOG Grey / 0 - 6 M
us Icon
$48.00
Delta Children Silver Slumber Nights Crib and Toddler Mattress - Grey
Delta Children Silver Slumber Nights Crib and Toddler Mattress - Grey
babylist Icon
$99.00
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
daVinci Jenny Lind Toddler Bed Rail & Reviews | Wayfair
daVinci Jenny Lind Toddler Bed Rail & Reviews | Wayfair
wayfair Icon
$89.00

Baby Gear

Ergobaby Metro 3 Compact Stroller - Onyx Black
Ergobaby Metro 3 Compact Stroller - Onyx Black
Fully Funded
Metro 3 Car Seat Adapter for Stroller | Ergobaby
Metro 3 Car Seat Adapter for Stroller | Ergobaby
ergobaby Icon
$40.00

Health & Safety

Dodo Babies Pacifier Clip Set - Four Clips Plus Binky Case - Universal Holder Fits Most Paci Brands, Teether Toys and Car Seats
Dodo Babies Pacifier Clip Set - Four Clips Plus Binky Case - Universal Holder Fits Most Paci Brands, Teether Toys and Car Seats
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$5.99
Momcozy Non-Contact Forehead and Ear Thermometer
Momcozy Non-Contact Forehead and Ear Thermometer
momcozy Icon
$19.99
MAM Matte Original Unprinted Pacifier 0-6M - 2pk
MAM Matte Original Unprinted Pacifier 0-6M - 2pk
target Icon
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
from
$6.59
MAM Comfort 1 Newborn Lightweight Silicone Pacifier
MAM Comfort 1 Newborn Lightweight Silicone Pacifier
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
from
$8.16
Jool Baby Magnetic Cabinet Locks (12 Locks, 2 Keys) - White
Jool Baby Magnetic Cabinet Locks (12 Locks, 2 Keys) - White
target Icon
babylist Icon
from
$24.99

Bathing

Etta Loves Colour Changing Bath Book
Etta Loves Colour Changing Bath Book
babylist Icon
$15.00
Out of stock
Plant-Powered Baby Shampoo & Body Wash (Tear-Free) | Puracy
Plant-Powered Baby Shampoo & Body Wash (Tear-Free) | Puracy
puracy Icon
$21.09
Baby Shampoo & Body Wash 2-in-1
Baby Shampoo & Body Wash 2-in-1
attitudeliving Icon
$12.95
Baby Hooded Towel - Cloud Island™
Baby Hooded Towel - Cloud Island™
target Icon
$14.00

Clothing

Nike Core Swoosh Baby Gripper Socks Box Set (3 Pairs)
Nike Core Swoosh Baby Gripper Socks Box Set (3 Pairs)
nike Icon
$12.00
CozyWay Baby & Toddler Socks With Grippers Non Slip Low Cut Grip Socks for Girls and Boys Soft Comfy Cotton 12 Pack
CozyWay Baby & Toddler Socks With Grippers Non Slip Low Cut Grip Socks for Girls and Boys Soft Comfy Cotton 12 Pack
amazon Icon
$14.98
​Chuck Taylor All Star Cribster Canvas Baby Mid Shoe. Converse.com
​Chuck Taylor All Star Cribster Canvas Baby Mid Shoe. Converse.com
converse Icon
$30.00
Vans | Infant Sk8-Hi Crib Black/True White Shoes
Vans | Infant Sk8-Hi Crib Black/True White Shoes
vans Icon
$35.00
Infant Classic Crew Socks 2-Pack in White | Vans
Infant Classic Crew Socks 2-Pack in White | Vans
vans Icon
$10.00
3-PACK COTTON JOGGERS
3-PACK COTTON JOGGERS
hm Icon
$24.99
3-PACK COTTON SWEATSHIRTS
3-PACK COTTON SWEATSHIRTS
hm Icon
$24.00
2-PACK CARGO JOGGERS
2-PACK CARGO JOGGERS
hm Icon
$16.99
Long-Sleeve Unisex Graphic Bodysuit for Baby | Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Unisex Graphic Bodysuit for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$5.00
Unisex Light-Wash Jean Jacket for Baby | Old Navy
Unisex Light-Wash Jean Jacket for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$13.49
Drawstring Barrel-Leg Jeans for Baby | Old Navy
Drawstring Barrel-Leg Jeans for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$19.99
Loose Jeans for Baby | Old Navy
Loose Jeans for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$24.99
Snug-Fit 2 Way Zip Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
Snug-Fit 2 Way Zip Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$7.49
2-Way-Zip Sleep & Play Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
2-Way-Zip Sleep & Play Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$10.00
Snug-Fit 2 Way Zip Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
Snug-Fit 2 Way Zip Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$10.00
Snug-Fit 2 Way Zip Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
Snug-Fit 2 Way Zip Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$10.00
Printed Crew-Neck Sweatshirt for Baby | Old Navy
Printed Crew-Neck Sweatshirt for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$8.99
Printed Crew-Neck Sweatshirt for Baby | Old Navy
Printed Crew-Neck Sweatshirt for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$11.99
2-Way-Zip Sleep & Play Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
2-Way-Zip Sleep & Play Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$7.79
2-Way-Zip Sleep & Play Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
2-Way-Zip Sleep & Play Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$6.49
Printed Sweatpants for Baby | Old Navy
Printed Sweatpants for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$19.99
Unisex Crew Socks 10-Pack for Toddler & Baby | Old Navy
Unisex Crew Socks 10-Pack for Toddler & Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$11.99
Printed Crew-Neck Sweatshirt for Baby | Old Navy
Printed Crew-Neck Sweatshirt for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$11.99
SoSoft Color-Block Cardigan Sweater for Baby | Old Navy
SoSoft Color-Block Cardigan Sweater for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$13.49
Short-Sleeve Ribbed T-Shirt and Chambray Jumpsuit Set for Baby | Old Navy
Short-Sleeve Ribbed T-Shirt and Chambray Jumpsuit Set for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$19.99
Ribbed Lettuce-Edge Biker Shorts for Baby | Old Navy
Ribbed Lettuce-Edge Biker Shorts for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$4.49
Unisex Short-Sleeve Bodysuit for Baby | Old Navy
Unisex Short-Sleeve Bodysuit for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$3.99
Sleeveless Tie-Knot Graphic One-Piece Romper for Baby | Old Navy
Sleeveless Tie-Knot Graphic One-Piece Romper for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$14.99
Printed French-Terry Ringer T-Shirt and Shorts Set for Baby | Old Navy
Printed French-Terry Ringer T-Shirt and Shorts Set for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$8.99
Printed French-Terry Ringer T-Shirt and Shorts Set for Baby | Old Navy
Printed French-Terry Ringer T-Shirt and Shorts Set for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$11.49
Pull-On Chambray Pants for Baby | Old Navy
Pull-On Chambray Pants for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$11.49
Long-Sleeve Fleece One-Piece Jumpsuit for Baby | Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Fleece One-Piece Jumpsuit for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$14.00
Printed Cami Bodysuit for Baby | Old Navy
Printed Cami Bodysuit for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$3.49
Rib-Knit Biker Shorts 2-Pack for Baby | Old Navy
Rib-Knit Biker Shorts 2-Pack for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$7.99
Rib-Knit Biker Shorts 2-Pack for Baby | Old Navy
Rib-Knit Biker Shorts 2-Pack for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$3.49
Unisex Bodysuit 3-Pack for Baby | Old Navy
Wants: Unlimited
Unisex Bodysuit 3-Pack for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$24.49
Unisex Bodysuit 3-Pack for Baby | Old Navy
Unisex Bodysuit 3-Pack for Baby | Old Navy
oldnavy Icon
$14.99
Baby cotton rainbow stripe beanie | Primary.com
Baby cotton rainbow stripe beanie | Primary.com
primary Icon
$29.50
Baby long sleeve pocket slub tee in double stripe | Primary.com
Baby long sleeve pocket slub tee in double stripe | Primary.com
primary Icon
$19.50
Gerber Baby 6pk Hat & Mitten Set
Gerber Baby 6pk Hat & Mitten Set
target Icon
$11.00

Diapering

Baby Wipes
Baby Wipes
attitudeliving Icon
$16.95
Premium Diapers | Rascals
Premium Diapers | Rascals
rascalsbaby Icon
$19.95
Disposable Diapers - Newborn Size - 162ct - up&up™
Disposable Diapers - Newborn Size - 162ct - up&up™
target Icon
$25.99
Kirkland Signature Baby Wipes Fragrance Free
Kirkland Signature Baby Wipes Fragrance Free
costco Icon
$21.99
Kirkland Signature Diapers, Sizes 1-2, 192 Count
Kirkland Signature Diapers, Sizes 1-2, 192 Count
costco Icon
$34.99
Kirkland Signature Diaper Size 1, 96-count
Kirkland Signature Diaper Size 1, 96-count
costco Icon
$14.99
Huggies Plus Diapers Sizes 1 - 2
Huggies Plus Diapers Sizes 1 - 2
costco Icon
$39.99
Pampers Pampers Swaddlers - 1 (96 Count)
Pampers Pampers Swaddlers - 1 (96 Count)
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
+1
from
$28.22
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
babylist Icon
$9.99 Was $11.49
walmart Icon
target Icon

It Takes a Village (Help & Favors)

Baby Books
Baby Books
Seamless Gift Cards | Customizable Gift Cards from Seamless
Wants: Unlimited
Seamless Gift Cards | Customizable Gift Cards from Seamless
seamless Icon
$20.00
Home-Cooked Meal
Wants: Unlimited
Home-Cooked Meal

Purchased

The First Years Sure Comfort 4-in-1 Reclining Bathtub
Purchased
The First Years Sure Comfort 4-in-1 Reclining Bathtub
Baby Play Mat Activity Gym,6 Developmental Zones Tummy Time Mat, Foldable Wooden Baby Play Gym with 7 Detachable Sensory Toys for Newborn Brain Development, Essential Baby Shower Set
Purchased
Baby Play Mat Activity Gym,6 Developmental Zones Tummy Time Mat, Foldable Wooden Baby Play Gym with 7 Detachable Sensory Toys for Newborn Brain Development, Essential Baby Shower Set
Cybex Aton G SensorSafe - Moon Black
Purchased
Cybex Aton G SensorSafe - Moon Black
Baby Banz Infant Hearing Protection Earmuffs - Prism
Purchased
Baby Banz Infant Hearing Protection Earmuffs - Prism
Evolur Lullaby Bedside Bassinet with Wheels, Seven Adjustable Heights, Breathable Mesh Sides Baby Bassinet, Large Storage Basket, Easy to Fold and Carry Travel Bassinet - Travel Bag Included
Purchased
Evolur Lullaby Bedside Bassinet with Wheels, Seven Adjustable Heights, Breathable Mesh Sides Baby Bassinet, Large Storage Basket, Easy to Fold and Carry Travel Bassinet - Travel Bag Included
New Boppy Nursing Pillow
Purchased
New Boppy Nursing Pillow
Comotomo Natural Feel Silicone Baby Bottles - Green, 5 Oz, 2
Purchased
Comotomo Natural Feel Silicone Baby Bottles - Green, 5 Oz, 2
daVinci Jenny Lind 3-in-1 Convertible Crib & Reviews | Wayfair
Purchased
daVinci Jenny Lind 3-in-1 Convertible Crib & Reviews | Wayfair
Stroller Organizer: Conveniently Organize Your Belongings
Purchased
Stroller Organizer: Conveniently Organize Your Belongings
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
Purchased
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Body Lotion for Delicate Skin with Natural Colloidal Oatmeal & Dimethicone - 18 fl oz
Purchased
Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Body Lotion for Delicate Skin with Natural Colloidal Oatmeal & Dimethicone - 18 fl oz
Motorola VM44 Connect 4.3" Connected Manual Pan/Tilt 720p Video Baby Monitor
Purchased
Motorola VM44 Connect 4.3" Connected Manual Pan/Tilt 720p Video Baby Monitor
Dr. Martens Kid's Collection 1460 Crib (Infant/Toddler) | Zappos.com
Purchased
Dr. Martens Kid's Collection 1460 Crib (Infant/Toddler) | Zappos.com
Chicco E-Motion Auto-Glider & Bouncer - Grey
Purchased
Chicco E-Motion Auto-Glider & Bouncer - Grey
Tripp Trapp® Classic Cushion
Purchased
Tripp Trapp® Classic Cushion
Stokke® Tripp Trapp® Baby Set² | Infant High Chair accessory
Purchased
Stokke® Tripp Trapp® Baby Set² | Infant High Chair accessory
Lovevery Anytime Activity Mat
Purchased
Lovevery Anytime Activity Mat
Fisher-Price Rock-a-Stack - Multi
Purchased
Fisher-Price Rock-a-Stack - Multi
Vans Slip-On V Checkerboard Crib Shoe - Baby - Black / White | Journeys
Purchased
Vans Slip-On V Checkerboard Crib Shoe - Baby - Black / White | Journeys
Universal Footmuff for Stroller, Baby Bunting Bags, Winter Windproof Warm Pram Footmuffs, Water Resistant Sleeping Bag with Hood for Strollers, Pushchairs, Prams, Car Seat, 30"*17.5"
Purchased
Universal Footmuff for Stroller, Baby Bunting Bags, Winter Windproof Warm Pram Footmuffs, Water Resistant Sleeping Bag with Hood for Strollers, Pushchairs, Prams, Car Seat, 30"*17.5"
Honest Baby Clothing 10-Pack Organic Cotton Baby Terry Wash Cloths - Rainbow Blues, Os
Purchased
Honest Baby Clothing 10-Pack Organic Cotton Baby Terry Wash Cloths - Rainbow Blues, Os
PADDED JERSEY BUNTING SUIT
Purchased
PADDED JERSEY BUNTING SUIT
PILE BUNTING WITH EARS
Purchased
PILE BUNTING WITH EARS
Babbleroo Travel Diaper Bag Backpack - Army Green
Purchased
Babbleroo Travel Diaper Bag Backpack - Army Green
Honest Baby Clothing 10-Pack Organic Cotton Tri-fold Burp Cloths - Blue Rainbow Gem, Os
Purchased
Honest Baby Clothing 10-Pack Organic Cotton Tri-fold Burp Cloths - Blue Rainbow Gem, Os
UWANTME Night Light, Dimmable Touch Lamp for Bedroom, Portable Bedside Table Lamps, 5 Brightness and 13 RGB Colors Night Light Suitable for Bedroom/Office/Bathroom/Hallways/Living Room
Purchased
UWANTME Night Light, Dimmable Touch Lamp for Bedroom, Portable Bedside Table Lamps, 5 Brightness and 13 RGB Colors Night Light Suitable for Bedroom/Office/Bathroom/Hallways/Living Room
Momcozy 4 in 1 Compact Bottle Sterilizer and Dryer
Purchased
Momcozy 4 in 1 Compact Bottle Sterilizer and Dryer
Frida Baby NoseFrida Nasal Aspirator
Purchased
Frida Baby NoseFrida Nasal Aspirator
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
Purchased
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
Pampers Pampers Swaddlers - Newborn (84 Count)
Purchased
Pampers Pampers Swaddlers - Newborn (84 Count)
Milou Modern Stacking Cups - Multi
Purchased
Milou Modern Stacking Cups - Multi
Zutano Organic Cotton Booties - Heather Gray, 0-3 Months
Purchased
Zutano Organic Cotton Booties - Heather Gray, 0-3 Months
Lovevery Drop & Find Ball Box
Purchased
Lovevery Drop & Find Ball Box
Manhattan Toy Wimmer Sense & Teether
Purchased
Manhattan Toy Wimmer Sense & Teether
Wee Gallery Tummy Time Gallery with Mirror - Black And White
Purchased
Wee Gallery Tummy Time Gallery with Mirror - Black And White
Ella Ola 3-Piece Bamboo Brush & Comb Set
Purchased
Ella Ola 3-Piece Bamboo Brush & Comb Set
SNOO Low Legs | Short Platform Baby Bed Legs – Happiest Baby
Purchased
SNOO Low Legs | Short Platform Baby Bed Legs – Happiest Baby
Hooded Bunny Baby Bath Towel
Purchased
Hooded Bunny Baby Bath Towel
Black Checkerboard Bapron
Purchased
Black Checkerboard Bapron
Ireland Mini Replica Ball by Gilbert
Purchased
Ireland Mini Replica Ball by Gilbert
Sprucely Back Seat Mirror - Black
Purchased
Sprucely Back Seat Mirror - Black
Polarized Baby Shades - Black
Purchased
Polarized Baby Shades - Black
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
Purchased
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
Itzy Ritzy Water-Filled Teether (3 Pack) - Cactus
Purchased
Itzy Ritzy Water-Filled Teether (3 Pack) - Cactus
Jool Baby Outlet Plug Covers (32 Pack) - Clear
Purchased
Jool Baby Outlet Plug Covers (32 Pack) - Clear
Jool Baby Multi-Purpose Adhesive Child Safety Strap Locks - White, 8
Purchased
Jool Baby Multi-Purpose Adhesive Child Safety Strap Locks - White, 8
The Honest Company Baby Wipes - Balance Blues, 576 Count
Purchased
The Honest Company Baby Wipes - Balance Blues, 576 Count
GOOtensil Pre-Spoons
Purchased
GOOtensil Pre-Spoons
Baby Spoons Regular Scoop | Stainless Steel & Silicone
Purchased
Baby Spoons Regular Scoop | Stainless Steel & Silicone