skip to main content
C+J

necessities for baby #2

Caitlin Allen & Jason Sieber
Pickerington, OH
December 19, 2025

Feeding

Dr. Brown's Options+ Narrow Glass Baby Bottle Starter Gift Set - White
Dr. Brown's Options+ Narrow Glass Baby Bottle Starter Gift Set - White
babylist Icon
$54.99
Out of stock
JL Childress Cool 'N Cargo Stroller Cooler - Black
JL Childress Cool 'N Cargo Stroller Cooler - Black
babylist Icon
$29.99
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
target Icon
Boon Cacti 4-Piece Bottle Cleaning Brush Set - Terracotta/Sage
Boon Cacti 4-Piece Bottle Cleaning Brush Set - Terracotta/Sage
babylist Icon
$16.99
amazon Icon
target Icon
booninc Icon
Momcozy Official Washing Block for Momcozy KleanPal Pro Baby Bottle Washer, 120 Detergent Tablets
Momcozy Official Washing Block for Momcozy KleanPal Pro Baby Bottle Washer, 120 Detergent Tablets
amazon Icon
$19.99
Dr. Brown's Anti-colic Options+ Narrow Glass Baby Bottle - 4oz, 2
Dr. Brown's Anti-colic Options+ Narrow Glass Baby Bottle - 4oz, 2
babylist Icon
$15.99
amazon Icon
Momcozy Portable Breast Milk & Water Warmer
Momcozy Portable Breast Milk & Water Warmer
babylist Icon
$79.99
walmart Icon
target Icon
Inglesina Fast Table Chair - Black
Inglesina Fast Table Chair - Black
babylist Icon
$89.00
amazon Icon
target Icon
Momcozy 9-in-1 Nutri Bottle Warmer
Momcozy 9-in-1 Nutri Bottle Warmer
babylist Icon
$49.99
amazon Icon

Sleeping

Baby Shusher Soother
Baby Shusher Soother
babylist Icon
$34.99
target Icon
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
Baby Sleeping Bag fits Infant Newborn,Warm Baby Sleeping Bag,Winter Newborn Knit Wool Swaddling Blanket Kid Sleepsack Footmuff Stroller Knitted Sleep Nest Sack (Khaki, One Size)
Baby Sleeping Bag fits Infant Newborn,Warm Baby Sleeping Bag,Winter Newborn Knit Wool Swaddling Blanket Kid Sleepsack Footmuff Stroller Knitted Sleep Nest Sack (Khaki, One Size)
amazon Icon
$19.99
Nivas Mobile - Ocean
Nivas Mobile - Ocean
babylist Icon
$55.00
The Honest Company Wash and Lotion Bundle - Calm (Lavender)
The Honest Company Wash and Lotion Bundle - Calm (Lavender)
babylist Icon
$19.49
target Icon
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
Crane Baby Cotton Sateen Crib Fitted Sheet - Caspian Whales
Crane Baby Cotton Sateen Crib Fitted Sheet - Caspian Whales
babylist Icon
$29.99
target Icon
amazon Icon
Hatch Rest Go - Mint
Hatch Rest Go - Mint
babylist Icon
$39.99
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon

Diapering

Pampers Swaddlers Baby Diapers (Newborn)
Pampers Swaddlers Baby Diapers (Newborn)
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
from
$28.22
Diaper Caddy Organizer - Versatile Basket for Diapers, Wipes & Baby Essentials - Perfect Baby Shower Gift, Car Storage, & for Expecting Mothers
Diaper Caddy Organizer - Versatile Basket for Diapers, Wipes & Baby Essentials - Perfect Baby Shower Gift, Car Storage, & for Expecting Mothers
target Icon
$22.99
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Baby Diaper Rash Cream Maximum Strength - 4oz
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Baby Diaper Rash Cream Maximum Strength - 4oz
babylist Icon
$9.99 Was $11.49
target Icon
walmart Icon
The Honest Company Clean Conscious Disposable Diapers - Above It All & Barnyard Babies - Size 1 - 78ct
Wants: Unlimited
The Honest Company Clean Conscious Disposable Diapers - Above It All & Barnyard Babies - Size 1 - 78ct
babylist Icon
$29.99
target Icon
amazon Icon
GREEN SPROUTS Muslin Cloths (5 Pack) - Blueberry
GREEN SPROUTS Muslin Cloths (5 Pack) - Blueberry
babylist Icon
$10.99
amazon Icon
Pampers Aqua Pure Natural Sensitive Baby Wipes
Pampers Aqua Pure Natural Sensitive Baby Wipes
amazon Icon
$34.23
Boogie Wipes Diaper Rash Spray - 1.7 fl oz
Boogie Wipes Diaper Rash Spray - 1.7 fl oz
babylist Icon
$9.97 Was $9.99
target Icon
amazon Icon

Baby Gear

Tushbaby Hip Seat and Snug Carrier Bundle - Cream Vegan Leather, Cream Snug Carrier
Tushbaby Hip Seat and Snug Carrier Bundle - Cream Vegan Leather, Cream Snug Carrier
babylist Icon
$177.30 Was $197.00

Health & Safety

Itzy Ritzy Silicone Pacifiers for Ages 6-18 Months - Itzy Soother Pacifiers Feature Collapsible Handle & Two Air Holes for Added Safety; Set of 2 in Agave & Succulent, Ages 6-18 Months
Itzy Ritzy Silicone Pacifiers for Ages 6-18 Months - Itzy Soother Pacifiers Feature Collapsible Handle & Two Air Holes for Added Safety; Set of 2 in Agave & Succulent, Ages 6-18 Months
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
from
$9.99
Itzy Ritzy Silicone Pacifiers for Newborn - Itzy Soother Pacifiers Feature Collapsible Handle & Two Air Holes for Added Safety; For Ages Newborn and Up, Set of 2 in Nautical Navy & Robin's Egg
Itzy Ritzy Silicone Pacifiers for Newborn - Itzy Soother Pacifiers Feature Collapsible Handle & Two Air Holes for Added Safety; For Ages Newborn and Up, Set of 2 in Nautical Navy & Robin's Egg
babylist Icon
$9.99
amazon Icon
Frida Baby DermaFrida The FlakeFixer The 3-Step Cradle Cap System
Frida Baby DermaFrida The FlakeFixer The 3-Step Cradle Cap System
babylist Icon
$16.99
target Icon
amazon Icon
walmart Icon
Haakaa Easy-Squeezy Silicone Bulb Syringe
Haakaa Easy-Squeezy Silicone Bulb Syringe
babylist Icon
$8.39
amazon Icon
Loulou Lollipop Silicone Teether - Monstera Seafoam
Loulou Lollipop Silicone Teether - Monstera Seafoam
babylist Icon
$11.99 Was $12.00
amazon Icon
Sprucely Cooling Teether (2 Pack) - Cantaloupe
Sprucely Cooling Teether (2 Pack) - Cantaloupe
babylist Icon
$9.99
Dr. Brown\'s Advantage Pacifier (4-Pack) - Blue Nature, 2
Dr. Brown\'s Advantage Pacifier (4-Pack) - Blue Nature, 2
babylist Icon
$8.99
amazon Icon
Pure Enrichment MistAire Ultrasonic Cool Mist Humidifier Silver: Bedroom & Baby Use, 1.5L, 25hr Run, No Filter Needed
Pure Enrichment MistAire Ultrasonic Cool Mist Humidifier Silver: Bedroom & Baby Use, 1.5L, 25hr Run, No Filter Needed
target Icon
$39.99

Bathing

BabyBond Baby Bath Kneeler and Elbow Rest Pad Set- Nonslip Kneeling Pad Bath Mat with Memory Foam and Bath Toys Organizer
BabyBond Baby Bath Kneeler and Elbow Rest Pad Set- Nonslip Kneeling Pad Bath Mat with Memory Foam and Bath Toys Organizer
target Icon
$39.99
Baby Dove Fragrance Free Moisture Baby Body Wash & Shampoo Hypoallergenic for Eczema-Prone Skin - 20 fl oz
Baby Dove Fragrance Free Moisture Baby Body Wash & Shampoo Hypoallergenic for Eczema-Prone Skin - 20 fl oz
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
from
$9.97
Frida Baby Control The Flow Rinser - Cup
Frida Baby Control The Flow Rinser - Cup
babylist Icon
$29.99
target Icon
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
Burt's Bees Baby Ultra Gentle Lotion with Aloe for Sensitive Skin, Pediatrician Tested, 99.0% Natural Origin, 6 Ounces
Burt's Bees Baby Ultra Gentle Lotion with Aloe for Sensitive Skin, Pediatrician Tested, 99.0% Natural Origin, 6 Ounces
amazon Icon
target Icon
from
$7.99

Nursery & Decor

Fitted Play Yard Jersey Sheet - Cream Checks - 2pk - Cloud Island™
Fitted Play Yard Jersey Sheet - Cream Checks - 2pk - Cloud Island™
target Icon
$9.99

Clothing

Personalized Bookish Kid Shirt, The Smallest Member of the Fellowship Baby Romper, Baby Shower Gift, The Shire Toddler, Newborn Gift
Personalized Bookish Kid Shirt, The Smallest Member of the Fellowship Baby Romper, Baby Shower Gift, The Shire Toddler, Newborn Gift
etsy Icon
$10.15
7AM Enfant Nido Velour Mild Climate Infant Wrap - Black Velour, 0-6 M
7AM Enfant Nido Velour Mild Climate Infant Wrap - Black Velour, 0-6 M
babylist Icon
$55.00
Out of stock
The Shire™ In Bloom Two-Piece Pajama Set
The Shire™ In Bloom Two-Piece Pajama Set
wildwoven Icon
$38.00
HAPIU Rayon from Bamboo Baby Footed Pajamas, 2 Way Zipper YKK, Footie for Baby Boy Girls, Newborn-24 Months
HAPIU Rayon from Bamboo Baby Footed Pajamas, 2 Way Zipper YKK, Footie for Baby Boy Girls, Newborn-24 Months
amazon Icon
$39.99
Newborn Baby Bear Outfit Suit Girls Boys Fleece Jumpsuit Romper Hooded Winter Snowsuit Clothes
Newborn Baby Bear Outfit Suit Girls Boys Fleece Jumpsuit Romper Hooded Winter Snowsuit Clothes
amazon Icon
$17.59
Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Hat and Mitten Set
Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Hat and Mitten Set
amazon Icon
$12.67
Tiny Kind Bamboo 3-Piece Outfit Set-Long Sleeve Bodysuit, Pants & Bib - Up Up Away, Nb
Tiny Kind Bamboo 3-Piece Outfit Set-Long Sleeve Bodysuit, Pants & Bib - Up Up Away, Nb
babylist Icon
$52.00
Snuggle Shield LUXE Bamboo Footie Pajamas 2 Pack - Heather Grey/White, 0-3 M
Snuggle Shield LUXE Bamboo Footie Pajamas 2 Pack - Heather Grey/White, 0-3 M
babylist Icon
$59.99
Out of stock
Tiny Kind Bamboo Convertible Footie Solid - Oat, Newborn
Tiny Kind Bamboo Convertible Footie Solid - Oat, Newborn
babylist Icon
$36.00
Goumi Kids Stay on Baby Booties (2 pack) - Stripe Gray/Midnight, 0-3 Months
Goumi Kids Stay on Baby Booties (2 pack) - Stripe Gray/Midnight, 0-3 Months
babylist Icon
$32.00
Out of stock

Playing

Electric Magic Dancing Octopus Toy, 2025 New Electric Auto-Avoid Crawling Octopus with LED & Music, Smart Interactive Auto-Wiggling Robotics for Indoor Play & Sensory Development (Yellow)
Electric Magic Dancing Octopus Toy, 2025 New Electric Auto-Avoid Crawling Octopus with LED & Music, Smart Interactive Auto-Wiggling Robotics for Indoor Play & Sensory Development (Yellow)
walmart Icon
$19.99
Blissful Diary Shell Baby Play Gym
Blissful Diary Shell Baby Play Gym
amazon Icon
$59.99
REMZO Baby Tissue Box Toy 3-in-1 w/ 10 Hanging Baby Crinkle Paper and Tummy Time Mirror - High Contrast Baby Toys for Newborn - Sensory Montessori Magic Tissue Box - Crinkle Books for Babies
REMZO Baby Tissue Box Toy 3-in-1 w/ 10 Hanging Baby Crinkle Paper and Tummy Time Mirror - High Contrast Baby Toys for Newborn - Sensory Montessori Magic Tissue Box - Crinkle Books for Babies
amazon Icon
$19.97
Wee Gallery Soft Block - Ocean
Wee Gallery Soft Block - Ocean
weegallery Icon
amazon Icon
babylist Icon
from
$36.95

General

Halfling Baby Onesie®, Cute Baby Onesie®, Funny Natural Baby Bodysuit, Baby Shower Gift, Hobbit Onesie®, Announcement Onesie®, LOTR
Halfling Baby Onesie®, Cute Baby Onesie®, Funny Natural Baby Bodysuit, Baby Shower Gift, Hobbit Onesie®, Announcement Onesie®, LOTR
etsy Icon
$6.49
Dreft For-All-Ages Laundry Detergent Bundle - 45 Count + 24 Oz Beads
Wants: Unlimited
Dreft For-All-Ages Laundry Detergent Bundle - 45 Count + 24 Oz Beads
amazon Icon
$35.91

4mom

Dermoplast Pain, Burn, and Itch Spray - 2.75 Oz
Dermoplast Pain, Burn, and Itch Spray - 2.75 Oz
babylist Icon
$9.49
target Icon
amazon Icon
Frida Mom Instant Ice Maxi Pad
Frida Mom Instant Ice Maxi Pad
babylist Icon
$19.99
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
The Honey Pot Company, Herbal Post-Partum Pads with Wings, Organic Cotton Cover - 12ct
The Honey Pot Company, Herbal Post-Partum Pads with Wings, Organic Cotton Cover - 12ct
walmart Icon
target Icon
amazon Icon
from
$8.38
Frida Mom Labor and Delivery + Postpartum Recovery Kit - Postpartum Must-Haves + Babyshower Gift for Mom
Frida Mom Labor and Delivery + Postpartum Recovery Kit - Postpartum Must-Haves + Babyshower Gift for Mom
babylist Icon
$99.99
target Icon
walmart Icon
amazon Icon
+1

Cash & Gift Cards

Babylist Diaper Fund
Babylist Diaper Fund
Any amount
Cash or check (in person or by mail)

Purchased

Skip Hop Suite Diaper Bag Backpack Set - 6pc
Purchased
Skip Hop Suite Diaper Bag Backpack Set - 6pc