Kelly & Sam’s Baby Registry
Kelly Rentschler & Sam Rentschler
Rutherford, NJ
January 2026
We’re so excited to welcome baby Rentschler this January. We are so grateful and excited to share this journey with you. Thank you for your love and support!
Feeding
Natural Breastfeeding Pillow, Nursing and Posture Support, Plant Based Cushion with Organic Cotton Removable Cover (Wheat)
$116.00
Bottle Washer Pro®: Automatic Baby Bottle Washer | Baby Brezza
babybrezza Icon
$259.99
8-Pack Organic Baby Bibs for Boys, Girls - Soft Cotton Drooling and Teething Bibs for Baby Girl & Boy, Extra Absorbent, Easy To Clean & Put On for Toddler, Newborn, Infant 0-24 Months (Prairie)
$15.96
AEIOU Bib (2 Pack) - Sage/Oat Milk
$19.00
Little Cup - Sage
$14.99
meetlalo Icon
from $14.99
Lalo 4pc Silicone Starting Solids Set - Sage
meetlalo Icon
$29.99
Sleeping
Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad
$129.99
Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet | Honest Baby Clothing
honestbabyclothing Icon
$19.99
Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet | Honest Baby Clothing
honestbabyclothing Icon
$19.99
KeaBabies Organic Bassinet Sheet for Baby Girls, Boys, 2-Pack Soothe Bassinet Fitted Sheets, Bedside Bassinet Mattress Sheet
$14.96
KeaBabies 2pk Isla Fitted Crib Sheets for Boys, Girls, Baby Crib Sheet, Fits Standard Nursery Crib Mattresses
$21.96
CozyChic Lite® Ribbed Baby Blanket
barefootdreams Icon
$85.00
Halo Super Soft Bamboo SleepSack - Storm Grey, Small
$44.99
Halo Super Soft Bamboo SleepSack - Blue Fog, Medium
$44.99
Halo SleepSack Swaddle Cotton - Blue, Small
$34.99
Swaddle Box
$79.99 Was $125.88
Diapering
Baby Diaper Cream Spatula 3 Pack Diaper Spatulas Soft Silicone Diaper Cream Applicator Baby Butt Paste Spatula Brush with Suction Base,Full Size(Gray+Off-white+Green
$6.99
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Rash Cream - 4 Oz
$9.99 Was $11.49
Baby Gear
Grab & Go Ultra Stroller Organizer - Black - Skip Hop | Carter's
$26.00
Silver Cross Wave Footmuff - Caramel
$149.99
Out of stock
Pack ‘n Play® Playard Fitted Sheets, 2 Pack
gracobaby Icon
$24.99
pipa™ aire rx + pipa relx base™
$650.00
nunababy Icon
from $650.00
BabyBjörn Baby Carrier Mini - Light Beige 3 D Jersey
$95.99 Was $119.99
20% off
Wants: 2
Shynerk Baby Car Mirror, Safety Car Seat Mirror for Rear Facing Infant with Wide Crystal Clear View, Shatterproof, 360° Rotation, Crash Tested and Certified
$17.59
Gaiatop Mini Portable Stroller Fan, Battery Operated Small Clip on, Detachable 3 Speed Rechargeable, 360° Rotate Flexible Tripod Better Cooling for Car Seat Crib Treadmill Travel Black
$15.98
7AM Enfant Stroller Warmmuffs Gloves - Anti-Freeze Stroller Mittens for Handlebars, Water Repellent Hand Warmer Muff for Cold Weather, Plush Lined Stroller Warmmuffs | Winter Stroller Accessories
$52.00
Health & Safety
No-Touch Thermometer for Adults and Kids, Accurate Digital Baby Thermometer, Fever Alarm & Silent Mode, 2 in 1 Forehead & Object Mode
$19.99
AEIOU Silicone Pacifier Clip - Sage
$14.00
Vulli Sophie la Girafe Teether
$31.99
Babylist Pacifier Box
$26.99 Was $32.46
Bathing
HonestBaby 10-Pack Organic Cotton Baby-Terry Wash Cloths, 10-Pack Bright White, One Size
$10.00 Was $19.99
50% off
Lalo Bathtime Fun Bundle - Coconut
$68.99
meetlalo Icon
from $68.99
The Baby Bundle | Tubby Todd Bath Co.
tubbytodd Icon
$64.00
Nursery & Decor
Bubble Knit Mist Blue Baby Stroller Blanket
$47.20
Honest Baby Clothing Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet | Gap
$15.00
Frenchie Cloudy Blue Organic Cotton Baby Crib Fitted Sheet by Leanne Ford
$44.95
Clothing
Baby 3-Piece Milk & Cookies Little Character Set® - Grey - Carter's | Carter's
$13.00
Baby & Toddler VintageSoft Relaxed Hoodie | Gap
$14.00
Baby & Toddler VintageSoft Washed Sweat Set | Gap
$49.95
Baby & Toddler VintageSoft Easy Joggers | Gap
$22.00
Baby Long Sleeve T-Shirt & French Terry Pants Set | Hanna Andersson
hannaandersson Icon
$48.00
Baby Faux Shearling Hoodie Jacket | Hanna Andersson
hannaandersson Icon
$55.00
Burt's Bees Baby Organic Cotton Booties - Heather Grey, 0-3 M
$19.95
Unisex 3-Pack Sleep & Play 2-Way-Zip Footed One-Piece for Baby | Old Navy
$38.99
Unisex 10-Piece Layette Set for Baby | Old Navy
$48.99
Baby Marshmallow Fleece Romper | Hanna Andersson
hannaandersson Icon
$60.00
Baby 7-Piece Short-Sleeve Bodysuits & Pull-On Pants Set - Blue - Carter's | Carter's
$31.20
Baby First Favorites Organic Cotton Footed One-Piece | Gap
$14.00
Baby First Favorites Organic Cotton Beanie (3-Pack) | Gap
$17.00
Bear Lovey and Rattle BEARY CUTE Gift Set | Honest Baby Clothing
honestbabyclothing Icon
$19.99
Multipack Cozy Socks Sustainably Made for Baby & Toddler | Honest Baby Clothing
honestbabyclothing Icon
$24.99
5-PACK WRAPOVER BODYSUITS
hm Icon
$24.99
Burt's Bees Baby Baby Girls' Mittens, No-Scratch Mitts, 100% Organic Cotton, Set of 3
$12.95
Playing
Skip Hop Discoverosity Montessori-Inspired 3-Stage Activity Center & Play Table for Baby Ages 4m+
$184.99
Skip Hop Farmstand Avocado Baby Stroller Toy
$10.99
Cloth Books for Babies (Set of 6) - Premium Quality Soft Books for Babies. Touch and Feel Crinkle Paper. Cloth Books for Early Children's Development.
$27.99
Gray and White Foam Play Mat | Emile - LIttle Nomad | House of Noa
thehouseofnoa Icon
$129.00
Cash & Gift Cards
Babylist Shop Gift Card
From $25 to $1,000
Purchased
Purchased
Fisher-Price Baby Playmat Deluxe Kick & Play Piano Gym for Learning & 2 Maracas Soft Rattles for Newborn to Toddler Play Ages 0+ Months
Purchased
LOVEVERY | The Play Gym | Award Winning For Baby , Stage-Based Developmental Activity Gym & Play Mat for Baby to Toddler
Purchased
Baby Brezza New and Improved Formula Pro Advanced Formula Dispenser Machine - Automatically Mix a Warm Formula Bottle Instantly - Easily Make Bottle with Automatic Powder Blending, Charcoal
Purchased
Silver Cross Wave/Coast Bassinet Stand - Black
Purchased
Newton Baby Essential Bassinet – Ultra-Breathable, Completely Washable, More Airflow for Safer, Cooler Sleep, Non-Toxic, Bedside Sleeper, Storage Shelf
Purchased
Mockingbird High Chair - Espresso
Purchased
Graco EasyTurn 360 2-in-1 Rotating Convertible Car Seat - Cyran
Purchased
Yogasleep Dohm Classic (White) The Original White Noise Sound Machine, Soothing Natural Sounds from a Real Fan, Sleep Therapy for Adults & Baby, Noise Cancelling for Office Privacy & Meditation
Purchased
Yogasleep Hushh 2 Portable Sound Machine (Grey) for Baby and Kids, Backlit Buttons & Night Light, Durable, 6 Soothing Natural Sounds, Easy to Use Timer, Volume Control & Toddler Lock, Noise Canceling
Purchased
BabyBjörn Bouncer Balance Soft - Cotton/Jersey/Mesh Sand Gray
Purchased
BabyBjörn Toy for Bouncer - Black/White Googly Eyes
Purchased
Small Story 6-Piece Organic Bath Time Set - Rain Drops
Purchased
Silver Cross Jet 5 - Full Size TSA Approved Infant & Toddler Travel Stroller - Lightweight, Compact & Easy to Fold, with All-Terrain Wheels and One Hand Full Flat Recline (Space Black)
Purchased
Munchkin Baby Bath Toy Squirts for Babies and Toddlers 9 Months and Up, Farm Animal Squirters, 8 Pack
Purchased
Pack 'n Play® Portable Playard
Purchased
Forma Backpack Diaper Bag - Black - Skip Hop | Carter's
Purchased
Frida Baby 3-in-1 XL Top Fill Humidifier for Bedroom, Allergy Relief, 6L Tank Cool Mist Humidifier for Large Rooms + Diffuser, Nightlight, Auto Shut-Off, Quiet, Carry Handle, Essential Oil Diffuser
Purchased
OXO Tot Nest Booster Seat with Removable Cushion - Gray
Purchased
Dreambaby Duck Baby Bath Thermometer – Instant Results, Digital Water & Room Temp Reader – Fun Floating Toy for Newborns
Purchased
Frida Baby Ultimate Baby Kit, 10 piece New Born Essentials Gift Set Includes Wellness Sick Day, Gas Relief, Grooming Tools & Teething Toys
Purchased
The Best Sellers Bundle
Purchased
Infant Lounger | Birch
Purchased
Newton Baby Breathable 2-Stage Crib Mattress - White
Purchased
Costzon Changing Table, Portable Baby Changing Table Foldable Diaper Changing Station with Safety Belt, Large Storage Rack & Shelf, Nursery Organizer for Newborn Infant (Black)
Purchased
Yoofoss Muslin Burp Cloths for Baby 10 Pack 100% Organic Cotton Baby Washcloths for Boys Girls Large 20''X10'' Super Soft and Absorbent Fog Blue
Purchased
Angelcare Baby Bath Support - Gray
Purchased
OXO Tot Perfect Pull Wipes Dispenser, Gray
Purchased
Parker Baby Diaper Caddy - Nursery Storage Bin and Car Organizer for Diapers and Baby Wipes - White, Large
Purchased
The Honest Company Clean Conscious Multi-Use Wipes | Hypoallergenic + Unscented for Sensitive Skin | Over 99% Water, Compostable, Plant Based, Baby Wipes | Pattern Play, 720 Count
Purchased
Inglesina Fast Table Chair - Mineral Gray Melange
Purchased
Keekaroo Peanut Changer Baby Vanilla– The Original Made in USA Easy-to-Clean Changing pad and The only Shell Over Foam, Fully Water Repellant
Purchased
Momcozy Portable Bottle Warmer
Purchased
Babylist Bottle Box (5 Bottles)
Purchased
Ubbi Ubbi x Babylist Matte Steel Diaper Pail - Matte White
Purchased
Baby Einstein Glow & Discover Light Bar Musical Activity Station and Tummy Time Toy, Montessori Cause and Effect Early Learning for 3-36 months
